Always Chasing Love? The Heartbreaking Truth About Pursuing—and How to Stop Pushing Them Away

You’ve seen it before—you just didn’t know what you were looking at.

Someone leaning in a little too hard. Asking too many questions.

Getting louder as the room gets quieter. On the surface, they might look controlling, dramatic, even aggressive.

But underneath? They’re hanging on for dear life.

The pursuer in a relationship isn’t hunting for power. They’re hunting for safety. For connection. For something steady to hold onto in a moment that feels like it could spin out of control.

And here’s the strange, cruel twist: the more urgently they reach out, the more likely they are to be left reaching.

Let’s talk about Kara and Jason.

It’s a Sunday night, the kind where nothing exactly goes wrong—but everything feels off.

They’ve spent the weekend in parallel silence.

Jason’s been sunk into his phone, half-answering questions, giving her just enough to let her know he’s still in the room but not in the relationship. Kara starts to feel the itch of it.

That tug in her chest that says: something’s not right. So she paces the kitchen and asks, “Can we talk?”

Jason doesn’t even look up. “I don’t want to fight,” he says.

But Kara doesn’t want to fight either. She wants to know she still matters. She wants to know he still sees her.

What she’s doing—what looks like nagging or pressing or picking a fight—is actually the most honest kind of vulnerability: she’s reaching out, not to control him, but to keep herself from unraveling.

He shuts down. She gets louder.

The space between them expands.

The more she chases, the faster he disappears.

Think of it like this: you get bad news. The kind that knocks the wind out of you. You grab your phone.

Not because there’s anything anyone can fix—but because you don’t want to be alone with the feeling.

That’s the pursuer’s instinct in a relationship. It’s not about winning an argument. It’s about survival.

It's the reflexive, almost primal need to make sure someone is there.

And when no one is? The panic isn’t metaphorical. It’s real.

Pursuers aren’t trying to create conflict. They’re trying to restore balance.

Their partner goes quiet, and it feels like the walls are closing in. So they talk more. Push harder.

Their inner alarms are screaming: Say something. Anything. Show me I’m not alone here.

But here’s where it gets tragic: what they mean as reaching out often lands as pushing in.

Urgency sounds like accusation.

Fear feels like pressure.

And to the partner who’s wired to retreat under stress, it all reads as danger.

So they withdraw, physically or emotionally. And that’s the moment the bottom drops out.

The pursuer is left in the silence, still shouting into the void—not because they want to be louder, but because it feels like they’re disappearing.

And for a pursuer, silence isn’t neutral.

It’s terrifying.

To discover Anxious Attachment Style and its role in Pursuing, click here.

When the Pursuer Burns Out

Not every pursuer keeps chasing. Some, eventually, stop.

Not because they’ve stopped caring—but because they’ve hit the emotional wall.

This is what burnout looks like in a pursuer: the questions stop, but the hurt lingers.

They go quiet—not with peace, but with resignation.

They start doing what their partner always wanted: less talking, less pressing, more space.

But it doesn’t feel like relief. It feels like loss.

When a pursuer burns out, it’s not the end of the conflict. It’s the beginning of emotional shutdown.

They stop trying to fix the relationship, and start silently grieving it instead.

If you’ve ever gone from pleading to numb, from pushing to shutting down, you may be a burnt-out pursuer.

And that deserves just as much attention. Just as much care.

That burnout isn’t a sign you’ve moved on—it’s a signal that your nervous system has gone into survival mode.

We wrote a whole article just for you.

It unpacks the emotional toll of chronic pursuit, how to recognize the signs of burnout, and what healing actually looks like from that place.

Because giving up doesn’t have to be the end.

It can be the turning point—if you know where to go next.

Read: When the Pursuer Burns Out and find your way back to yourself.

Inside the Pursuer’s Panic: What You Don’t See

From the outside, the pursuer might look relentless.

Their voice gets sharper. Their questions repeat.

They follow their partner from room to room like a lawyer trying to crack a case.

But what you don’t see—what’s happening just beneath the surface—is something closer to collapse.

They’re not trying to interrogate.

They’re trying to breathe.

Inside, the pursuer is spinning. Their nervous system has slipped into red alert.

The heart races. Breath shortens. Their skin buzzes like a live wire. Their brain starts throwing out words—any words—that might pierce the distance.

It’s not rational. It’s reactive. The same way your hands would reach out if you started to fall.

And that’s exactly how it feels: like falling.

Take Marissa and Eli.

It starts with something small. Eli’s quiet. Distracted.

His eyes stay on his phone a little too long. Marissa feels the shift instantly—like a cold draft sneaking under a door.

So she asks, “What’s wrong?” He shrugs. Doesn’t look up. She asks again. Then again.

The questions get faster, louder: “Why won’t you look at me?”

“Are you hiding something?”

She follows him through the hallway, her voice rising.

“You don’t care,” she blurts out, her voice breaking.

But here’s the thing: she’s not lashing out. She’s reaching out.

Her words may sound angry, but her fear is the one driving.

“Please don’t leave me alone in this,” is what she really means.

But Eli doesn’t hear that.

He hears accusation.

He hears criticism.

And so he shuts down. Marissa feels the rejection hit like a slap.

And just like that, they’re no longer having the same conversation. They’re not even in the same emotional room.

They’re standing in the same hallway, and still—somehow—miles apart.

Here’s the invisible script that runs through a pursuer’s mind during those moments:

I feel invisible.
I can never get through.
If I stop trying, you’ll leave.
I matter less every second you don’t respond.

These aren’t just passing thoughts.

They’re ingrained beliefs—deep grooves carved from earlier chapters in their life.

For some, it goes all the way back to childhood.

Or from an “Attachment Injury” she experienced with him or from a previous relationship.

Maybe their feelings were met with indifference.

Maybe they were taught—implicitly or explicitly—that love had to be earned.

That attention had a cost. That connection was conditional.

And so they adapted.

They became vigilant. Hyper-attuned.

Wired to chase connection the moment it felt like it might slip.

Not because they’re dramatic or needy—but because at some point, they learned that the worst thing you could be was forgotten.

Which means this moment—this silence, this distance, this non-response—it isn’t just hard.

It’s terrifying.

This isn’t about being too emotional.

It’s about survival.

And unless someone sees that—really sees it—the loop keeps going. The pursuer reaches.

Their partner the distancer retreats. Both feeling misunderstood.

Both feeling alone.

Pursuing is an Adaptive Survival Response

There’s a reason the pursuer doesn’t let go.

There’s a system at work—quiet, invisible, urgent.

At the center of it is a simple idea: “If I can just get you to see me—really see me—I’ll stop feeling so alone.”

Pursuing isn’t about control.

It’s about hope.

Hope that if they say the right thing, show the right emotion, express how badly they need this relationship to work, then something in the other person will switch on.

That connection will return. That the ground under their feet will stop shaking.

But when it doesn’t happen—when their partner, the distancer, withdraws or freezes or offers that cool, almost dismissive shrug—the pursuer’s brain doesn’t just register disappointment. It sounds an alarm.

I’m too much.
I don’t matter.
I’m on my own again.

And that’s when everything escalates.

The voice sharpens.

The questions come faster.

The pressure tightens.

Because to a pursuer, silence isn’t just silence.

It’s rejection in disguise.

This is the moment—the pivot—where things turn toxic. And they turn fast.

The pursuer starts to feel like a character trapped in a game with no winning moves.

If they ask gently and get no response, the panic creeps in.

If they press harder and are met with anger or coldness, they spiral.

Either way, they lose.

It’s a double bind.

In trouble if they do. In trouble if they don’t.

And in that pressure cooker, the emotional volume keeps rising.

Frustration. Anger. Resentment. All building.

But what never quite breaks the surface—the part no one sees—is the vulnerability underneath it all.

The soft center that never gets spoken aloud.

That’s the tragedy of the pursuer.

They want closeness so badly that the way they reach for it often pushes it further away.

Their words sound like criticism, but their hearts are full of grief.

Their tone might be sharp, but it’s the sound of someone begging to be held.

A broken heart, misunderstood by the very person they’re trying to reach.

What’s happening inside the pursuer is a kind of emotional double exposure.

The outer layer—the one their partner sees—is agitation. Criticism. Demands.

But underneath it, like a second radio frequency only a few people know how to hear, is a mix of fear and sadness and longing.

They’re not trying to win the argument. They’re trying to stop the free fall.

And half the time, they don’t even know that’s what they’re doing.

They just know they feel terrible, and they want the terrible to stop.

One workshop participant said it best:
“When she lashes out, I used to get defensive. Now I see the scared part inside her. It changes how I respond.”

The anger? That’s not the threat. That’s the signal.

It’s the flare they shoot into the sky when they’re scared they’re disappearing.

If you stop at the anger, you miss the plot.

And the plot is this: they’re terrified.

Terrified of being left.

Of being unimportant.

Of loving someone who might already be halfway out the door.

And when they finally snap—when their voice goes too high or their words go too far—they’re often shocked too.

They didn’t want to cause pain. They were trying to stop their own.

But the pain overwhelmed them.

And in trying to fix the disconnection, they created more of it.

That’s the cruel paradox. The emotional trap.

And the only way out is to understand what got them there in the first place.

To Read about Anxious Attachment Style and Pursuing, Click Here.

What Pursuit Actually Looks Like

It’s easy to miss pursuit in real time—mostly because it doesn’t always look like fear.

It looks like intensity. Like pressure. Like someone pushing too hard.

But if you slow it down—if you freeze the frame and zoom in—you’ll see the pattern.

It’s not random. It’s a strategy.

A desperate, improvised, half-conscious strategy to reestablish connection.

Here’s what it looks like in the wild:

  • The same question asked three times in five minutes, each one louder than the last.

  • A body trailing after their partner from room to room, unwilling to let the conversation die.

  • Accusations and criticisms—not to hurt, but to provoke a response. Any response.

  • Demanding clarity when things feel vague. Demanding closeness when things feel cold.

  • Reading silence not as peace, but as a flashing “Exit” sign.

From the outside, it might look irrational. But inside, it’s a form of survival.

These aren’t manipulative moves. They’re protective ones.

Because for the pursuer, even a fight is better than being ignored.

Anger means the connection still exists.

A slammed door still proves someone’s home. But a blank stare? That’s the abyss.

And that’s why they keep pushing.

The pursuer doesn’t want conflict—they want confirmation.

They want to know the relationship still has a pulse.

But here’s the most painful irony of all:

While they’re fighting to close the distance, they’re often creating more of it.

The harder they press, the more likely their partner is to retreat.

Their partner doesn’t hear the fear underneath.

They hear pressure. Judgment.

A rising tide of expectation they don’t know how to meet.

So they shut down. They withdraw.

They do the very thing that terrifies the pursuer most.

And now both people are hurting. Both feel misunderstood. Both are locked in a story where the other person is the villain.

But underneath all the noise and misfires, they’re chasing the same thing.

The pursuer wants to feel safe. Their partner, the distancer, wants to feel safe.

They just speak different dialects of distress.

And that’s the heart of it all:
This isn’t a fight about who’s right. It’s a plea to feel secure.
To know: you still care. You’re still here. I still matter.

That’s the real pursuit.
Not control. Not drama. Just the human need to belong—clumsily, urgently expressed.

So, are you the pursuer in your relationship?

At Healing Broken Trust, we meet you right where you are: rocked by betrayal, standing in the wreckage of infidelity, yet burning with a desire to reclaim your marriage, your family, your future. Most solutions out there? They’re not built for this fire.

They’re too slow, too shallow—counseling that drags, books that skim, conversations that loop back to pain.

You’ve tried them. You’re still here, hungry for something that moves you forward.

We feel that.

Brad, a licensed marriage and family therapist, and Morgan, we’ve lived the sting of infidelity in our own families.

We’ve seen it ripple, breaking not just hearts but legacies. That’s why we poured everything into the Healing Broken Trust Workshop—a high-octane, trauma-informed, research-driven experience that doesn’t waste your time.

In three days, you’ll rebuild emotional safety so you can breathe, dismantle the resentment and shutdowns, master communication that sparks respect and closeness, and heal wounds that rob your peace.

You’ll walk out clear, strong, with a relationship you can trust again.

The proof? 98% of couples leave feeling better—relationship satisfaction soaring from a 4 to an 8.

This isn’t talk.

It’s transformation.

You’ve survived the worst.

Now let’s build what’s next—together.

Go here and take the leap.