Who’s Right? Is it an Emotional Affair or Not?

Emotional infidelity: A common scenario I often encounter is when one partner feels deeply hurt and wounded because they believe they have caught their spouse in an emotional affair.

The partner engaging in conversations with someone else denies any emotional involvement, insisting they are just friends.

But who’s right? Who’s wrong? And what impact does this have on a couple’s relationship?

What Is Emotional Infidelity?

Emotional infidelity occurs when one partner forms a deep emotional connection with someone outside the relationship, crossing boundaries of intimacy that should be reserved for their significant other.

Unlike physical infidelity, which involves sexual activity, emotional cheating thrives in secret conversations, growing attachments, and misplaced loyalties.

It often begins innocently—a coworker who listens when a spouse is too busy, a friend who understands their sense of humor when their partner seems distant. But over time, the connection intensifies, and the primary relationship weakens. 

Researchers Ami Roach and Sybil Chan, in their article “Love and Infidelity: Causes and Consequences,” define emotional infidelity as “the occurrence of emotional involvement with a third party that violates the ground rules established by the couple (e.g., placing trust in someone else, sharing deep personal thoughts, falling in love with another person, being emotionally vulnerable, demonstrating greater commitment to someone else, or prioritizing financial investments in another).”

The Impact of Denial and Emotional Detachment

What happens when the participating partner denies any emotional involvement and dismisses their spouse’s concerns?

Relationship injuries occur whenever one partner feels devalued by the other. Some wounds are small—like feeling criticized or believing your spouse is always working and unavailable.

But as these experiences build, they become more painful and destructive, with infidelity ranking among the most devastating betrayals.

When someone suspects their spouse of being unfaithful—emotionally or otherwise—but is met with denial, minimization, defensiveness, mockery, emotional distance, or a lack of reassurance, the injury deepens.

Instead of healing, the betrayed partner is left feeling even more isolated and invalidated.

At the core of relationship injuries is a violation of expectations. We expect our spouse to be emotionally present, to love and support us through life’s ups and downs—for richer or poorer, in sickness and in health.

But when those expectations are shattered—when our partner withdraws, gaslights, or retaliates—the emotional wound becomes even more profound.

Have you seen our blog article on Warning Signs of Emotional Infidelity?

Have you seen our blog articles on Limerence

Have you taken our quiz “Is It an Emotional Affair?”

If your relationship has been shaken by betrayal, you don’t have to navigate the pain alone.

Our Healing Broken Trust workshops and online programs are designed to help couples move beyond the devastation of infidelity and rebuild a stronger, more connected marriage.

Through expert-led guidance, proven strategies, and compassionate support, you and your partner will learn how to heal emotional wounds, restore trust, and create a relationship that feels safe, secure, and fulfilling again.

Whether you’re struggling with lingering resentment, painful triggers, or communication breakdowns, these workshops and online programs will give you the tools to reconnect and move forward—together.

Are you struggling to just survive infidelity and betrayal? Join us for our next expert-led workshops and support. We have specific programs for couples and for those who have been unfaithful and betrayed. Click here to learn more about our couples program, click here for more about our programs for the betrayed partner, and click here for more info about our programs for unfaithful partners.

References:

Rokach A, Chan SH. Love and Infidelity: Causes and Consequences. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2023 Feb 22;20(5):3904.