Ep 21: 10 Types of Affairs

Morgan:

If the person that you're striking up a friendship with knows more about your relationship and what's going on than your spouse does, then you're heading down that path.

Brad:

Yeah.

Morgan:

You are listening to Healing Broken Trust podcast with Brad Morgan Robinson, where we talk about healing from affairs, infidelity, trust, and cheating in your relationship from the perspective of a professional marriage therapist and a fair recovery expert. If you want to save your relationship after infidelity, this podcast is for you. Welcome to episode 21 where we're talking about the 10 different types of affairs. We're asking the question, are all affairs created equal? This is a really important question because not every situation is going to look exactly the same. It will help you to know and recognize the different types of affairs that are out there so you can know how to handle your unique situation better. And if you haven't already done so, go to healing broken trust.com/episode 21. That's the number 21, and download the resources that go along with this episode. Also, if you haven't yet seen the information on our one-on-one retreats and you'd like more personalized help, check out the retreatsPage@healingbrokentrust.com slash retreat today. And let's get started. You don't see specialty group private practices where the entire practice is devoted to working with couples or just one area of specialization,

And that's what we do. We specialize in relationship therapy. The average therapist out there might see three or four couples a week, but we see 50 couples every week coming through our office. On average, every therapist who works with us is committed to researching the best methods for working with couples. And research has shown that the more common method for working with couples was only about 35% successful, and only 17% of the couples actually maintained their improvement after two years.

Brad:

That's

Morgan:

Research,

Brad:

And that's a huge relapse, really,

Morgan:

Definitely one of the methods that we use emotionally focused couples therapy has also been researched, and it was discovered that 86% of couples make significant improvement in counseling. And that's the couple saying that they've made significant improvement.

Brad:

Right? Yeah. Not the therapist saying, Hey, they got better. It's the couples saying they made significant improvement, not just improvement.

Morgan:

Exactly. And then they followed those couples and they found three years after counseling, 90% of those couples actually kept their progress, which is a big deal. I mean, people usually want to know, is this going to help us? Are we going to get back to where we were again? And so that's a big difference.

Brad:

Yeah, is it's

Morgan:

Huge. It's

Brad:

A huge difference.

Morgan:

We help relationships related at any place, whether you're wanting to stop your divorce, wanting to remarry after divorce, or maybe you're just wanting to prepare for marriage or you're just having trouble connecting with each other. So we really help relationships really to any place. Today we're talking about the different types of affairs, and there are 10 different types of affairs that we've identified, right, Brad?

Brad:

Yeah. There's at least 10 different types. And these are just categories just to understand if you've gone through an affair, if you're in one of these categories, your affair is in one of these. It may not be a complete description of it, so it may be like we're going to talk about there being a one night stand, and then we're going to talk about somebody who's a burned out spouse. Maybe there's a combination of these different categories at times. So not every affair nicely fits into these categories, but we've put 'em into categories to help us understand them,

Morgan:

And that's really important.

Brad:

So there's 10 different types. I'll just briefly list off the names of these 10 different types. So there is the one night stand, there is the liran affair, there's the sex addicts affair. There is the shared interest affair, the emotional affair. There's the idealized love affair, and there's the philanders affair, the sexual abuse affair. And I'll explain that. Lemme just because that's going to throw people off. That's basically when someone's abused, taken advantage of and their spouse thinks that they were having an affair, but they were actually raped or they were sexually abused. Oh gosh. And that obviously is very complicated because the one who was abused is their spouse thinks they cheated on 'em and they were actually taken advantage of. And then there's the revenge affair, and that's when someone's been betrayed. They want to get even with their spouse and they get 'em back.

And then the exit affair, there's the one night stand and the one night stand, this very well may be a one time betrayal. It can be more than one time, and it can happen more than one time without that person being a sex addict. And so there's a fine line between a few one night stands and being a sex addict to really be diagnosed as a sex addict. You don't want to meet with a therapist that specializes in that, which is something that we can do at marriage solutions. You don't want to self-diagnose yourself with something like that. You can have more than one night stands, but commonly one night stands occur when a spouse is away from home, usually on business or a pleasure trip, something like that. And they happen in the heat of the moment. They give into temptation, and that usually happens when there's drinking and they can be anonymous.

So they're traveling business pleasure by themselves. There's drinking. They give into temptation boundaries, poor boundaries, things like that. Now, when this kind of affair happens, it's not necessarily an indication of problems in the marriage or that the betrayer is dissatisfied with her spouse. In fact, one of the distinguishing points in this type of affair is the betrayer wants to stay in their marriage. So sometimes we get people who have an affair, and one of the common elements is they're burned out. The marriage really has issues, but they really want to be a part of the marriage. This is someone who can be happily married and still does this because alcohol is involved. They're away from home, but maybe they're curious, some temptation involved.

Morgan:

You want to talk about the characteristics.

Brad:

The core of this material is really bad choices, bad boundaries, the lack of integrity mixed with the opportunity to act. Typically there's no emotional involvement. And it happens typically with a perfect stranger who's befriended in this situation. And we've worked with plenty of people with this, and this can be very hard to understand and make sense of why did this happen? As we talked about before, getting to why and understanding why it makes it more bearable, not knowing why just makes us much harder.

Morgan:

We've been able to help people recover their relationship even after this.

Brad:

Oh yeah, definitely. So this type of affair, the one night stand may be motivated out of loneliness or curiosity just generally result to poor boundaries and misguided thinking that this could never happen to me. I'm going to get close to the edge of the line, but I'm not going to cross it. Normally, individuals who have had one night stands tell themselves that they will go to the grave with this secret. I'm not telling anybody this is not an indication that they want out of the marriage. In fact, they fear that if they tell this secret, they're going to lose the marriage. And that's really the wrong approach with that. And

Morgan:

That's something that we've talked about in the past, being completely open and forthright and honest, because that really is what begins the healing process for the

Brad:

Relationship.

Morgan:

This hiding doesn't help

Brad:

But the one night stand basically. Obviously they don't want to disclose it, then the whole marriage is going to be shattered. So characteristics of this type of affair, it's really an affair of convenience or opportunity. It's not something that's really sought out, but rather it occurs as the opportunity is presented. The berio does not want to leave the marriage. That's another characteristic. And then it's not really an ongoing relationship. It happened a couple times. A relationship can develop from this. And one of the ironic things with this is when people are betrayed, especially when it's a one night stand, they say, gosh, this would be so much easier if you had a relationship with this person. I can understand it better. And then when people have been betrayed by their spouse having a long-term relationship, they're like, gosh, you just had a one night stand.

Morgan:

And everybody thinks the grass is greener on the either side.

Brad:

Yeah, exactly. They think the grass is greener. And here's the important thing, if you're listening to this and you've been the one who had the affair, it's just as hard. Even if it was a one time mistake or year long mistake, it's still just as hard. There's different elements that maybe make it harder as far as pain goes. Either one's about a 10,

Morgan:

About painful.

Brad:

Yeah. And then

Morgan:

Are these typically sexual relationships? We've talked about emotional affairs we talked about.

Brad:

Yeah, they're typically sexual. Yeah. Okay. It's pretty, alcohol is involved. Yeah, it's typically just pure sex and that kind of thing. Let's go on to the liran affair.

Morgan:

So the liran affair, this type of affair is really characterized by two different or two individuals who believe they are in love and with this type betrayers believe that they have fallen in love. It's the love addiction affair that we've talked about, and they feel powerless over powerful emotions. It's not uncommon for them to feel guilty about what they're doing, but at the same time, they feel like they are no longer in love with their spouse, and they know that they will never be happy unless they're with their lovers. So it's this guilt complex we talked about where they want to go home to their spouse and they want to be there with their spouse because they feel guilty. But the whole time they're really thinking about this love object that we've described it as in the

Brad:

Past, Morgan, you hit the nail on the head. They feel guilty about having the affair, but also they're miserable at home. And so they go home to their spouse because they feel bad about having the affair. But then when they're home, they crave being with the affair partner because of that limerence catch. And we talked about limerence before, but they crave that limerence. And so then they'll go back to the fair partner. And so they bounce back and forth and it can really stretch out over a period of time.

Morgan:

Yeah. And usually it develops from an existing friendship that begins really where the boundaries have been breached. And so basically those boundaries, they weaken and then they finally give in. And I think it's really interesting, something we've talked about in the past that sometimes people in a limb and affair, they really, really try to quit it. They really try to go back to their spouse and then they go back to work or where that person may be, and all of a sudden they see them in the hallway and it's like a light switch switches, and they're like, oh my gosh. And they fall into this lime affair again. They fall

Brad:

Back to it again.

Morgan:

And it's like an addiction. I love addiction.

Brad:

Yeah. Morgan, what you were saying is important. Usually this kind of affair starts as a friendship first. It begins as the boundaries between the two individuals weaken. This type of affair is not like the one nine stand. It's not based on sex necessarily

Morgan:

The ideal of that person.

Brad:

Yeah. Well, it's the feeling of being in love.

Morgan:

Oh, yes.

Brad:

In fact, the power driving the relationship, it's really the strong emotions generated by the growing romance

Brad:

And

Brad:

It's thence. We've talked about this before. I'll just remind our audience. Rin is a fancy term to describe a few basic feelings of love, love, sickness, infatuation, obsessive love, love addiction. It's this romantic love. And so when people are having a liran affair, they're feeling this romantic love feeling, and it really starts a growing romance. And that's why they want to leave their spouse and be with this person.

Morgan:

The betrayer believes he or she wants out of the marriage. So they think they want out of the marriage. The betrayer believes he or she is in love with the affair partner and is willing to sacrifice life with their spouse for the opportunity to be with the affair partner. And typically, this type of affair is a long-term relationship versus the one I stand where it's very temporary and very one night standish.

Brad:

Yeah, it's a long-term relationship that develops into romance develop.

Morgan:

And then frequently there's a pattern of betrayer swinging back and forth between their marriage and their affair partner. And when they are at home, like we talked about trying to do what's right, they're miserable and they feel like they'll never be happy. And when they're with their affair partner, they have this euphoria, this ecstatic euphoria, but they may be feeling so guilty that they can't stand it. So they move back home only to feel miserable and to realize once again that they can never be happy unless they go back to the affair partner. So it's this back and forth, back and forth dance. And then this dance of insanity can continue for years. So this back and forth can happen for a very long time. Versus the one night stand, maybe short betrayers often seem incapable of making a decision about what they're going to do, and they don't want to be in the marriage. Other factors may keep them from choosing to divorce, for example, feelings of guilt or failure may cause them to stay. There may also be strong feelings regarding what's best for the kids. So they may decide to stay for the children, but a lack of commitment to the marriage is a real problem. So

Brad:

Choosing to leave isn't the solution. But this kind of affair too, Morgan, I want to include this and this type of affair with limine affairs. The betrayers have most likely already made the decision to leave their marriage when people are experiencing kind of made up the mind, I think I'm done. I don't think I want to be here anymore. And so we'll see them come to counseling usually out of respect or something like that.

Morgan:

But at that point, most of the time they've decided that they're done. They already decided care for their spouse.

Brad:

They just want to end on good terms. And so that's usually why they come to

Morgan:

Counseling. But we've been able to help people break out of the li and affair and actually rekindle their relationship with their

Brad:

Spouse. Yeah, yeah, definitely. And so they want to leave. They've already made the decision to leave. They believe they can't be happy unless they get to be with the one they love.

Unlike the one night stand, this kind of affair indicates a deeper problem in the marriage. The marital problem is not the cause of the fair necessarily, but there are defects in every marriage. And sometimes those defects definitely play a role in an affair. And so at the very least, they can serve as inhibitors to the betrayer wanting to work on the marriage. Well, you've got these flaws, you've got these things. Why do I want to stay with you? And part of that is limerence at play. And part of that's just the reality of that's what marriage is like. Everybody has issues.

Morgan:

And we talk about you put two flawed human beings who're not perfect, and you put 'em together and you think, oh, it's a perfect union, but there's no such thing. You've got two flawed human beings. You're going to have a relationship with flaws.

Brad:

So

Morgan:

It's

Brad:

Natural. Well, and let me say this, Morgan, because one of the things, I know people listening to us talking about this, if they're in this, they may think, well, holy crap, this is hopeless. They want to leave. They're in love. They no longer love me. They feel like our marriage has issues. They went out of their marriage. They've been bouncing back and forth for a long time. It's not hopeless. One of the key things of overcoming a lime Orrin affair is really the person experiencing limerence, knowing that it's RINs, just them knowing, okay, I'm experiencing, and here's the characteristics. These are the factors that go into that. And we've got a show on that that we've already done. But just knowing that many times, that causes people just to put on the brakes

Morgan:

And to understand what's going on with

Brad:

Them because they think they're in love. They think they found their soulmate, and many times they're grateful to know that, Hey, this is what they're experiencing. And so that's one of the key things. And the other key thing is when you do this, and we haven't discussed this yet, but you have to start doing last resort techniques. You have to start doing things as a spouse when they've decided they want to leave.

Morgan:

And that's something that you've really developed a lot. The last resort technique, when your spouse is trying to leave you when they're done, there are ways to actually save your relationship.

Brad:

And I'll just briefly go over that, and we're going to do this in a future show. Basically there's four things that you want to do, and these are one sided. But when you're trying to get someone back, they're leaving for very specific reasons. And so we're going to discuss those in a different show. We're not going to get into those today, but there's things that need to be done. And so it's not hopeless at the very least.

Morgan:

Yeah, definitely. It's not hopeless. We can definitely help. There are ways to rekindle the relationship. And today we're talking about the different types of affairs. There's 10 different types, but we are on the third, the sex addicts

Brad:

Affair, the sex addicts Affair. These affairs are committed by individuals. This could be male or female, to have an ongoing pattern of sexual betrayal such as frequenting, topless bars or adult bookstores, viewing pornography, compulsive masturbation, prostitution, repetitive encounters with sexual partners and other behaviors that are destructive to both the individual and to the marital relationship.

Morgan:

So this is kind of that stereotypical one that everyone thinks, oh, if they've made the mistake of having an affair, that they all kind of are lumped into this category. But it's not entirely true that everybody is,

Brad:

No, it's not a sex addict. Not everybody who has a one night stand is a sex addict or goes to topless bars. Whoever better be that goes to topless bars is not a sex addict. But here's the important thing with this. If you have, I would say a majority of these things that we just listed, a pattern of sexual betrayal, like topless bars, adult bookstores, viewing pornography, compulsive masturbation, prostitution, repetitive encounters with sexual partners, those can be evidence of a sex addict. And let me say this, I know we talked about one night stand a few minutes ago, when a sex addict has a one night stand. This is someone who seeks out the opportunity for sex. And so I had a guy one time I worked with, he would pick up women from bus stops on his car and he would have sex with 'em. And he did this 17 times. So he had 17 one night stands,

Morgan:

Oh my gosh, that he

Brad:

Could remember, that he could remember at this point. And the guy is a sex addict. Now those a little bit more than one night stands. And so if you've traveled for business and you've had one night stands, you may not be necessarily a sex addict. You probably have very bad boundaries, but it is worth exploring so that you can get the right treatment for it. Because one of the things in rebuilding your marriage back is the behavior has to stop. Trust has to be rebuilt. And each time that a one night stand reoccurs, you are demolishing any sort of progress that's been rebuilt.

Morgan:

And these people that are seeking out these sexual relationship, there's not even really a relationship. Sexual experiences. Sometimes they feel like they just can't find the fulfillment in their marriage.

Brad:

Yeah, yeah. It's

Morgan:

A deep void.

Brad:

Well, even though they're married, they haven't found complete fulfillment from their marriage. In fact, they're enslaved by desire to satisfy their longings. They're driven by obsessive thoughts and compulsive behaviors. They're powerless over their extramarital attachments to these behaviors to people or objects like pornography. They're really powerless to this. These individuals look to extramarital attachments to meet the need for love and acceptance instead of allowing their mate to fulfill these needs.

Brad:

And

Brad:

So this is really important. What they have is they have a huge amount of toxic shame. They feel really unacceptable as a person. They feel unlovable. They feel shame is what gets them into sex addiction. And these individuals are looking for sex to meet the need for love and acceptance that they have. And unfortunately, it just creates more, and I'm going to get into this in a minute, but that shame that comes from being a sex addict just creates, in fact, more of a compulsive need for sex addiction.

Morgan:

This category is not about the marriage as much as it is about the addiction. Is that correct?

Brad:

Yeah. Yeah. Sex addicts don't typically have affairs because there's issues with the marriage. Now, they may blame the marriage when they get caught. Well, you did this to me one time, or that happened, or this happened. So that's my excuse for seeing topless bars and pornography and having a string of 17 women. They can use that as an excuse, but not that the marriage didn't have issues, but that's them trying to save face. Most likely, they would've pursued these same behaviors whether they were married or not, or if they were married to Miss America, they still would've pursued these kinds of things. And so this is key. The shame and fear associated with this type of behavior perpetuates the dual life of an addict propelling the destructive behaviors. It just creates more of this. And so they often feel hopeless. They feel trapped by these behaviors, and they're afraid to come clean because they don't want to lose their marriage or give up their addictive behavior. And so this type of betrayal, it's especially difficult for the spouse who's been betrayed because their suffering is not just from the betrayal, it's from their inability to understand their mate's behavior.

What the addict has done seems so foreign. The spouse cannot comprehend it. So finding out why is really important in this.

Morgan:

Yeah, that why is so important.

Brad:

Yeah. One of the things a sex addict could do is even have sex with someone of the same gender when they're not a homosexual, they could still have a sex with someone of the same gender, and that really makes it hard. And so figuring out why, what makes it hard to recover is not knowing why,

Morgan:

Because they really have a deep void that needs to be filled. It's

Brad:

A shame. Shame and the guilt. Yeah. There's so much shame there. I'm such a bad person and they're trying to remove that toxic shame. I'm such a bad person that they're looking for sex and acceptance. It's

Morgan:

Almost like sometimes self abuse, sometimes pursuing something that will

Brad:

Exactly. Yeah. I'm just going to go through these characteristics real quick. One of the things that can happen with this is when the betrayed spouse, they're in such a shock because it is outside the norms of healthy sexuality, obviously. And so they're so shocked about this

Brad:

At

Brad:

The magnitude of the compulsive behavior that makes it also difficult for a couple to recover.

But the characteristics of this is it's a habitual pattern of extreme behaviors that are either sexually related or they're relational. So that means somebody can have a series of flings that are emotional affairs, like through text messaging or emails or things like that, and not quite reach sex, but they may have phone sex or something like that. Typically, the betrayer wants to save the marriage, but they still have a compelling drive to look elsewhere to meet their needs. They want to save the marriage, but they still have this compelling need to be a sex addict and act out sexually. Often these behaviors began before the marriage, and this was really important. They stopped after they got married, and then they began again after the addict realized that being married couldn't meet the needs that they have the same way as acting out does

Brad:

The addictive

Brad:

Behaviors. And so that's really important. So they may stop for a little bit and then kind of go back to it after getting married. It is common for the betrayer to have made past efforts to stop the behavior and to have actually been successful for a season only to relapse after believing things were better.

Morgan:

They

Brad:

Kind of feel like to

Morgan:

Let their guard down,

Brad:

They feel like, well, I can stand over the edge of this cliff and look down. And this is important. And this is a huge part of why this sex addiction continues is betrayer has a deep sense of shame and guilt, and the behavior creates more shame and guilt, and they have tons of shame that leads them into this kind of lifestyle

Morgan:

Negative cycle.

Brad:

Yeah, just reinforces it. The sex addict needs to be an individual counseling for their addiction. Being remorseful, not cure a sex addict, you need to go to a therapist who specializes in this. Recovering from an affair is not possible until the betrayer gets the help they need for their addiction. I say this because unless they get the help they need, it will happen again and again until this is dealt with directly.

Morgan:

And what's really important is you really need to go to someone. You can't just say, oh, my spouse is a sex addict, but you're not the therapist. So go to a qualified person before you just make the assumption that they're an addict.

Brad:

Because a sex addiction diagnosis is a heavy diagnosis and you need to make sure that it's a legitimate diagnosis, something that you have to fill out. And yeah, that's legitimate. In Oklahoma, one out of six couples will do marriage counseling with a professional before divorce, which is really low. That is low. That's pretty bad. But it talked about the lime affair, and we're going to talk about the second type of the liran affair. This first type is more the classical type of liran affair where a person feels like they're madly in love with someone and they want to leave the marriage because they want to be with that person as their soulmate. But may happen is they may leave the marriage to be with that person and then come back. They may leave home to be with that person, and then when they're away, they feel guilty, so they'll come back home. And that's just a stance of insanity that

Morgan:

Happens. And then while they're at home, they feel the longing to be with their other

Brad:

Partner, the other person. And that puts you through the grinder when you go through that. Then there's a sex addicts

Morgan:

Affair, and there's very, a small percentage of people that actually have a sex addiction

Brad:

Affairs. Yeah, actually there's a very few number, but when they do, it's very clear because it's a lot of people,

Morgan:

A lot of people that they've had an affair with is what you're saying.

Brad:

Yeah. The shared interest affair, that's what we're going to talk about today, the emotional affair and the idealized love affair, which is the second type of limmer and affair. We're going to talk about Flanders men and women who are Flanders, who think it's pretty much normal or morally to have sex. They cross the line and they don't think they're cheating or they think it's okay to cheat

Morgan:

Sex outside of marriage, right?

Brad:

Yeah. It could be sex, it could be kissing other types of sex other than intercourse. Then there's a sexually abuse affair where someone's sexually abused their spouse. Mistakes set for an affair, the revenge affair. This is when someone's been betrayed and they don't have their spouse to help them try to heal, and they want to make them feel the same pain they have. So the revenge affair and then the exit affair. And so the shared interest affair, and let me say this before we get into this. Every affair, these are put in the categories. Some of this is information that I've created. Some of this is information from Rick Reynolds. He's a therapist down in Austin, and some of this is from Dave Carter who's also, and all three of us work with infidelity, and there's pretty much about 10 different types of affairs, and there could be more than that. But just for the sake of classification, they're put into 10 different types of affairs. So not every affair may clearly fit into one category that we're discussing in this series of types of affairs. So may not fit perfectly. There may be more than one category that your affair sits into. And so it's good

Morgan:

To know.

Brad:

It's very important to know that. So the shared interest affair in this situation, the betrayer, they'll be involved with a single person, and at the same time, they don't want to leave the marriage to the person having the affair. They look at their fair partner as a soulmate. And these affairs frequently spring from a relationship in which the two individuals share something in common, such as music, art, or other interests. Could be movies, it could be technology, it could be just something that they don't have in common with their spouse.

Brad:

And

Brad:

So they turn to the affair partner for understanding companionship and support. It is as if the betrayer develops two lives, they share one part of themselves with their mate, and then they reserve another aspect of life for their affair partner.

And pretty much every affair has, I would say most affairs have some element of this where they kind of have a duality. You kind have a secret fantasy life, but this is a little bit more developed in this type of affair. So let me repeat that last thought. The betrayer will develop two lives. They share one part of themselves with their mate, and then they reserve another aspect of life for their affair partner. Daily activities and information are divided into two realms that which will be shared with her spouse and that which will be shared with the affair partner. Usually this type of affair indicates that there are other deficits in the marriage.

Morgan:

There's just a lack of closeness, and somehow

Brad:

There could be a lack of closeness. There could be closeness, it could be lack of time together, that kind of thing. Lemme be clear here. Marital problems is no excuse for infidelity. Just because you have issues doesn't mean it's okay to go cheat.

And those are areas that need to be addressed in order to strengthen the marriage. So some of the common characteristics of this type of affair is the individuals want to stay married who have the affair. It's unusual for the affair partner to be referred to as a soulmate. It can't happen, and there may be a little bit of limerence in this type of affair as well. The betrayal's life is divided into two parts, the part shared with their spouse and the part they share with the affair partner. So in two different distinct needs are being met by these two different relationships. An important part of figuring out why and this kind of affair is asking, how are you different?

Morgan:

Interesting. Yeah,

Brad:

Because why is an affair? Because you're different in this type of relationship. You like how you feel in that. So asking how you're different would help understand a little bit more of the motivation, why someone had that affair and what they were drawn to. And so Morgan, the next part is the emotional affair.

Morgan:

This fifth type of affair is commonly referred to as an emotional affair. This is the fifth on our list, although some would not consider an emotional entanglement, an affair because it hasn't been consummated. And a lot of people don't see it.

Brad:

If you're not having sex, it's not an affair,

Morgan:

Which that's what they might think. But truly,

Brad:

That's what betrayers many times think.

Morgan:

Yeah, this type of relationship can be just as devastating and destructive as a sexual affair. Emotional affairs are not commonly discussed. And frequently their lack of sexual involvement, like we said, is used as to why it's not an affair. But technicalities in no way absolve the reality of the situation. So usually when a person has to put the word just in front of the word friend, there's a problem. The notion that a lack of sexual involvement somehow prevents this type of relational intimacy from being an affair. And it really is baffling. And anytime someone other than our mate is permitted to enter the most intimate areas of our life, we're just giving something that we have no right to give, and we have already given and committed our heart to another, to our spouse. And so sharing intimate details of your life with someone else other than your spouse, that's an affair. One good way to identify this type of affair is if your mate's best friend,

Brad:

Best friend,

Morgan:

Yes, has more information or insights about your mate's life than you do, does this friend know more about your marriage than you do if your mate is closer to a friend than to you? It is already an affair. And it may seem harmless because they've yet to cross the sexual physical line, but it is an affair nonetheless. And a lot of times these do lead to the physical affair. So the characteristics really are boundary issues. That's a factor. The betrayer is better friends with that individual than his or her spouse. The betrayer keeps secrets with his friend instead of with his or her spouse. The betrayer does not want to choose between the friend and the spouse, and the betrayer wants to stay married. Usually this one seems more sneaky to

Brad:

Me.

Morgan:

It seems a lot more sneaky. It kind of sneaks in.

Brad:

Yeah. People honestly have a hard time knowing if it's an affair.

Morgan:

The

Brad:

One who's been betrayed, they say, yes, it's an affair. The one who was involved in it many times, they don't feel like it was an affair because, oh, it's just my friend. I did talk about things, but they were telling me things. They were telling me about things going on with them. And so a little bit more, I want to go over a few more things that kind of help clarify this. It's an emotional affair if you're keeping the details of this relationship secret from your spouse, that's one way to note. It's an emotional fear. So you're keeping the details of this relationship secret from your spouse, you're saying, and doing things with the other person that you wouldn't do with your spouse present. So you're saying or doing things with this other person that you wouldn't do with your spouse present.

Morgan:

If your spouse wasn't there, you probably would change your tune.

Brad:

Maybe you wouldn't even go to that area. You're sharing things with the other person that you wouldn't share with your spouse, and you're making an effort to arrange to spend time with the other person. And this is important too. People who get involved in emotional affair typically weren't looking for an affair. They didn't intend to have an affair, and they didn't think they were vulnerable to having an affair. And so that's really important.

Morgan:

And the truth is, we're all vulnerable. We have to always keep our antenna up, our antennas up

Brad:

And about half of emotional affairs do develop into a physical relationship.

Morgan:

Interesting.

Brad:

And about 79% of people weren't seeking an affair. Were not seeking an affair. And that's information from dear peggy.com. He was an affair recovery expert as well. And so many times people just think it's harmless. But the fact is that these things do turn sexual. And many times the distance between no physical contact and kissing is a longer distance between kissing and physical intimacy.

Morgan:

Will you say that one more time?

Brad:

Yeah. That the distance between no physical contact and kissing is a much longer distance than when people start kissing. And the

Morgan:

Physical

Brad:

Intimacy that develops,

Morgan:

It's much easier to go from kissing to physical.

Brad:

It's just a natural progression of things. And so that's an emotional affair. The next type of affair, and this is the other type of a lime affair,

Okay, strongly lime idealized love affair. This is a love addiction that's characterized by repetitive pattern of moving from one relationship to the next, falling into a love that doesn't exist. Although this pattern has an addictive quality to it, these are not necessarily sexual relationships. They also do not fall under the category of people who have become emotionally involved in an inappropriate friendship. There is a compulsive pattern to their behavior. It is about the feeling of falling in love with that one right person. So this type of affair is about the feeling of falling in love with that one right person of

Morgan:

Butterflies, that you get that thing.

Brad:

And of course they can't find that one right person. So this never ending search for the one right person prevents full commitment to a marriage. And having discovered that their mate isn't the right person, Mr. Or Mrs. Wright, these people will compulsively pursue the search for their soulmate. And we've had this in our office where people will come in and want to leave their spouse because they think they found their soulmate, they think they found it, and they've met their spouse through an affair as well.

Brad:

And

Brad:

So it's kind of this progression like this, and it's really, they're looking for that falling in love, that perfect fairytale type relationship

Morgan:

That doesn't, that's not accurate, doesn't

Brad:

Exist

Morgan:

Realistic,

Brad:

And they're looking for the right person instead of trying to be the right person.

And so falling in love is not this falling in love thing that they're looking for is not love at all. When this occurs, it is not even about the other person. It's how it makes them feel about themselves. Anyone who has fallen in love will eventually fall out of love and then must choose to love because love grows in stages. You have the romantic love, then you experience disillusionment, and then you have mature love where you choose to love. So anybody in every relationship moves past romantic love, nature's way of helping us bond with each other, develop a relationship with each other, but it moves on to disillusionment, begin to see flaws and weaknesses. And then you have to choose to

Brad:

Love.

Brad:

And these people keep thinking, well, crap, I want this romantic love feeling. I like this being in love feeling. And they keep looking for that. And when it ends with one relationship, they go to the next for it. And so pretty much anyone who has fallen in love is going to fall out of love. And you have to choose to love

What real love is. True love is based on knowing the other person and letting that person know you. This is a healthy intimacy and not this false intimacy. The love addict has mistaken for love. They've clung to and obsessively pursued, and that's that part of limerence. So characteristics of this, it occurs in male and females, but it can happen more often with females. The betrayer will be ambivalent about their marriage. They also tend to overvalue the person they're infatuated with. They may think this person is the greatest thing ever. They're incapable of judging the negative characteristics of the affair partner. While they may see the defects, they won't give these defects any weight, whether they see them as unique or special. So even the negative flaws of this person they look at is unique or special.

Morgan:

And is that before they actually join in a relationship with that person and then see more clearly, or is it just like an infatuation that wears off over time? Is that

Brad:

It could be, yeah. Usually it wears off over time

Morgan:

And then they start to see those flaws maybe differently at that time when the infatuation wears

Brad:

Off. Well, yeah, they'll notice 'em as flaws then. But when they, they're involved in and this in love feeling, they don't even really consider, many times they don't even consider the weaknesses. And when they do, they might look at it as, oh, he only has a temper because he's just passionate about stuff. Yeah, he's a passionate, he gets so passionate, he punches holes in the wall. Gosh, I love somebody who's so passionate about

Brad:

Life.

Brad:

That's how they'll look at it. It could be something that silly so occurs more often with females. They tend to be ambivalent about their marriage. I love my spouse, but I'm not in love with my spouse.

We'll hear that, and that's a sign of this kind of affair or even any affair really. But they tend to be ambivalent. They've experienced this kind of relationship with someone else, and they want to try to recreate that with their spouse, and they may decide to leave them and they don't feel that emotional bond that's there. They also tend to overvalue the person they're infatuated with. We were talking about that a moment ago. They're really incapable of judging the negative characteristics of the affair partner. And that's because of nce. And we talked about that before in a previous show. The Thence is also known as love sickness, love addiction, infatuation, obsessive love, romantic love, and it really just clouds your judgment on how you see things. These defects may be seen, they don't really consider it. They may see 'em as unique or special, kind of what I was talking about with the anger. This may not be an actual relationship with a person they're infatuated with. It could be like an obsession that's not reciprocated

Morgan:

Interesting.

Brad:

So it could be somebody they work with.

Morgan:

It's like a challenge.

Brad:

It could be like a challenge, but that's also how ence works. It's when eye contact's made. It's when you find someone that you think is attractive or you think that's interested in you, and there's eye contact with them. Many times, that's kind of when Rin starts. We've talked about that progression.

Morgan:

It's fall. That's the fall

Brad:

Like

Morgan:

You talked about. Yeah.

Brad:

And so they may not even have a relationship with this person. And these betrayers will often frequently complain about the lack of romantic love in their relationship. They feel like they've married the wrong person,

Morgan:

The marital relationship. Yeah.

Brad:

They'll complain about the lack of love in their marital relationship, and they'll complain about, gosh, I think I married the wrong person here. And they'll experience obsessive thoughts about the romantic partner, this lime object. And that's really what happens is this person becomes objectified that they feel in love, they're in love with. They wouldn't say that, but that's typically how psychologists described this experience. This person becomes an object. They experience obsessive thoughts about this new romantic partner. They spend time, they spend as much as 80% of their time awake thinking about this person trying to determine how this other person feels about 'em. And the obsessive nature of this relationship creates unrealistic expectations of the love object. So this kind of relationship, but they're so obsessed with it that they create unrealistic expectations, interesting of this person that they're in love with. This person's got to be God or walk on water, or they have these really unhealthy, unrealistic views of who this person is.

Morgan:

And you had mentioned just a couple of seconds ago about most of the time they feel like, well, maybe they married the wrong person, but it seems like a lot of these affairs, they might say that, well, I just don't know if I married the right person. But I could imagine once you dig in and find out, well, why they had the affair, what the reasons are, how they view their relationship and love and that other person, that's when you can determine that it's this really, we shouldn't be pathologizing our spouse or trying to just based on one radio show trying

Brad:

To figure out, because these affairs, honestly, every affair has a lot of these characteristics,

The duality between the spouse and the affair partner, the feeling of love, feeling like you've made a mistake. There's a lot of commonality in a lot of these different types of affairs. But what we've done is we've really classified these to make it easier to understand what's happening in those affairs. One of the key things to understanding why is really asking that question, and we've been over this before, but it's worth repeating, how are you different in this affair? That's so important because a lot of this, as you can see from each one of these affairs, it goes from someone to talk to someone I have a shared interest in, and then someone who I think is this right person. Yeah. The soul need. It goes from these different experiences, and each person going through an affair has different

Brad:

Motivations.

Brad:

And so just to classify one, it's always this way. It's not always that way.

Brad:

There

Brad:

May be similarities, but these categories are helpful in just understanding where your spouse is at. And if you've had an affair, you may fit in more than one category. You may fit in two categories or three categories. In recovering from an affair, it really, it's important to disclose all secrets. And that's very hard for people to do because the person who had the affair has so much shame and embarrassment. They feel like talking about the affair only makes it worse for their spouse. But healing from an, it's important to be honest, transparent, and show your spouse that you're willing to do whatever it takes. And if it's difficult to talk about the affair, you need to talk about your fear with your spouse on why this is so difficult for you because your spouse thinks that you don't care about 'em or they think you're still involved in the affair. But if you talk about how this is difficult for you to talk about this, how you're afraid of making them hurt, how you're ashamed, don't want to relive this, how you want to put this behind you, the guilt is so strong that will help your spouse begin to heal as well.

Speaker 6:

But

Brad:

Your spouse is going to keep asking for answers and want to talk about it, talk about your fear, talk about how hard this is for you to talk about it. That's okay too.

Morgan:

It's a great place to go and

Brad:

Start. It's a great place to start.

Morgan:

And we've said in the past, the first 90 days are the hardest. It's, would you say two years to rebuild the

Brad:

Trust? Yeah. Typically it depends on how well couples manage that negative cycle if they get into. And that's what we try to help couples really with. And honestly, you don't see that too much in a fair recovery, especially some of the books or information online.

Morgan:

You don't see what too much.

Brad:

You don't see people really address the negative cycle, in my opinion. They give you instructions on how to talk about it, but they don't talk about the motivations behind each person, what they're needing. And so getting professional help dealing with the negative cycle, because ultimately honesty is important for building trust, but ultimately what helps you heal besides the honesty is the emotional connection with your spouse. And you've got to get out of the negative cycle because the negative cycle you're trying to heal with many times is the negative cycle you had before the affair.

Morgan:

And the negative cycle is that pattern of a

Brad:

Bit pattern of interacting,

Morgan:

Interaction, yeah,

Brad:

Yeah. Attacking each other of avoiding each other. So you got to deal with that.

Morgan:

Right. Do you want to recap what we talked about and then we'll go on to the last few?

Brad:

Yeah. There are 10 different types of affairs. I've identified some of these. Rick Reynolds from Austin, Texas has identified some of these as well, 10 different types of affairs. There is the one night stand, this occurs generally when someone has had too much to drink and being anonymous is involved, they want to stay in the marriage. It's not an ongoing relationship at times. It can morph into an ongoing relationship though. And let me pause and say this, Morgan, we're categorizing these affairs for the purpose of understanding them. Our listeners who have gone through an affair, their affair may contain more than one category. Kind of like I was saying a moment ago about the one night stand that can lead into a relationship. I've seen that in my office. It begins that way, but then a relationship starts so it becomes an emotional affair. Your affair, your experience may not fit nicely into only one category can be divided into two or three categories. And so this is just to help us understand things better. So there's the one night stand, we talked about that. And then there's the liran affair and liran affairs. This is more the classic liran affair. There's another liran affair that we talked about last week, but in this classic liran affair, this is when two people feel like they're in love and they feel powerless over these emotions of love. And limerence is that feeling, and we've spent time talking about this too.

It's that feeling of infatuation love, romantic love, obsessive love. When you're not around that person, you feel despair. You wonder, do they feel that way about me? So there's despair there. So they want to be with their affair partner. And then what can happen as well is there is feelings of guilt because you see what you're doing to your family, what you're doing to your spouse. And in fact, we had someone in our office this past week, very first session who came in with this, and this is kind of that classic liran affair. And so you see this, it can kind of grow in stages, so you don't always see at this level of maturity. This guy's been at, and let me say this,

Brad:

He

Brad:

Was already in that place of ambiguity after one month of experiencing this. So that liran feeling develops quickly and it causes doubt

Morgan:

Sometimes by locking eyes that someone could fall into this love sickness that's

Brad:

Infatuation. They think they either find that person attractive and they lock eyes with 'em. And then the other part of that is they feel like that person could be interested in them. Those are things that are at play

Morgan:

And it's the love object that we've talked about

Brad:

To Yeah, they're a love object,

Morgan:

The object that satisfies their imagination.

Brad:

And so when someone experiences a limmer and affair, they believe that they want out of the marriage. Sometimes it's a friendship that's developed into a romance. The betrayer is willing to sacrifice life as they know it, to have the opportunity to be with that affair partner, this dance of insanity, of going back and forth between the marriage and the affair partner, the guilt and the shame about leaving, and then the ecstasy when they're with the affair partner. That can continue for a long time. And so then the next type of affair that we discovered was a sex addicts affair. We discussed characteristics of sex addiction. What happens with that?

Morgan:

And there's a very small percentage of affairs that are actually, because we think that sex addiction is every affair. When we look at it on TV or something like that, people assume it must be just like 99% of the affairs are,

Brad:

And I'm not a sex addiction expert, but I would say very little has been sex addiction or very extreme cases of sex addiction.

In our practice, we've seen at least 200 couples, probably with an affair. I can easily think of three that had an extreme case of sex addiction. And then there's people involved in pornography, and that's not necessarily sex addiction, but I can think of three, maybe four out of 200. So it'ss not as common as the media portrays it, but it's also, it's something that's very real. Then we talked about the shared interest affair. This is when the beary is involved with a single person, but at the same time, they don't want to leave the marriage and then to the person having an affair, they view this person as a soulmate and the betrayer wants to stay married and their life is divided into two parts. The part shared with their spouse and the part that's shared with the fair partner, and they feel like two different sets of needs are met in those two different relationships. Sometimes these affairs frequently spring from a relationship where these two individuals share something in common, such as music, art, or another interest could be anything, computers, and they're just techies and they like discussing that kind of thing.

Morgan:

They connect on

Brad:

That level, they connect on that level, and so it's something that they don't share in common with their spouse. So they turn to the affair partner for understanding companionship and support. Then we talked about the emotional affair, and most affairs obviously have an element of emotional of what an emotional affair is. We talked about that boundary issues are a factor, how the betrayer can be better friends with this person than with their spouse. How the becher can keep secrets with this person instead of with their spouse, how the betrayer doesn't want to have to choose between their friend and their spouse, and ultimately the becherer does want to stay married.

Morgan:

Some for that one is if the person that you're striking up a friendship with knows more about your relationship and what's going on than your spouse does, then you're heading down that path.

Brad:

Yeah, yeah, exactly. That's a good point. And this is the other limmer and affair that we talked about. I call this the I want to be in love affair. There's two different types. The one that we described earlier with the guilt and the ambiguity about staying and going where the guy after a month had already just been liran with someone was already kind of wanting out of the marriage. And then this is the other liran affair. I want to be in love affair, and this is kind of a love addiction that's characterized by repetition, repetitive pattern of moving from one relationship to the next, falling into a love that doesn't last, kind of keep looking for the perfect person, the perfect love. The perfect love experience is really what they're looking for. It's

Morgan:

An idealized, just an idealized version of a human being,

Brad:

And it occurs with men and women. I've seen it happen with both. They're all about falling in love more than anything else, and they've got to find that one right person. That's a search that never ends. They've bought into a lie. It's almost like a fairytale they've bought into.

Morgan:

Someday my prince or princess will come.

Brad:

Yeah,

Morgan:

We've talked about that.

Brad:

Then the a flander is affair, and the flander is someone who basically believe that cheating is justifiable. It's morally in some way, as long as it's not intercourse, it's okay. Honestly, you'll see this a lot. People who go to a lot of these conventions for work or trade shows, things like that. A lot of these conventions, there's a lot of people hooking up at those kinds of things, like a one night stand. They're anonymous, maybe not any alcohol involved, but they'll have these different things. And in a way, it's kind of like this, Hey, what happens in Vegas stays in Vegas. It's this kind of flander attitude they may have and they can be influenced by a parent who was a cheater.

Morgan:

It's kind of a rite of passage. Yeah.

Brad:

I remember my dad telling me his dad was a cheater, and my dad telling me one time that having an affair was a rite of passage. And I remember thinking, dad, that's the dumbest thing anybody's ever told me that you've ever told me either. And that was he's older and he's from a different part of the country. That's just part of his generation or his mindset at the time.

And the people that are most the harm with this are people who, honestly, I think it's morally just people who have lack of integrity, the moral factor, people who they think it's okay for me to do it, but if you were to do that, me as a man, it's okay, but for you as a woman to do that, that's not acceptable. And so there's a double standard there, obviously. And then some cultures, I have an unsaid expectation that men will have women on the side, and some women are okay with that. And so that's a kind of flander affair, and we talked about that a little bit more detail last time. Then I want to get into the sexual abuse affair.

Morgan:

So basically this is the eighth type of affairs that we've identified, and this affair occurs when somebody has been raped or forced into sex by another individual, but the spouse of that person doesn't believe that he or she has been taken advantage of, so it's quite tricky. Maybe sometimes that person has experienced an emotional affair. Maybe they've had an emotional

Brad:

Affair. Yeah. Morgan, you some examples of this while we're talking about this so people can understand. Well, I had a situation one time where a woman was having an emotional affair

Brad:

With

Brad:

A guy, and when it turned sexual, she resisted it. She didn't want to go sexual, and the guy raped her, basically he raped her against her will. So the

Morgan:

Husband didn't believe her.

Brad:

Yeah. Had a very hard time believing that something like that happened. He's dealing with his own pain, doesn't trust her. He's been deceived enough. He's like, well, this is a pretty creative deception. So he had a hard time believing that. And then another time, there's a third time, I've seen this a few times. Another time this happened is where, and that's actually happened a couple of times where women have gotten raped and their husbands,

Morgan:

It's very hard for them to believe

Brad:

That. Yeah, it's very hard to believe it because of the boundaries they were crossing

Morgan:

And the trust that was violated

Brad:

Originally. Yeah, and I know this probably is a little controversial as talking about this, it's very hurtful for the person who's been involved. There's shame from being abused like that and then turning for support and not getting it. So both people are suffering and getting help with this type of affair, I would say is very vital.

Someone who's got experience in working with affairs and with couples, it's very, very, very important because it is just vital. Another time where I've seen this is a guy that knew a female that he worked with. She was sending him pictures. He didn't tell his wife anything about it. He didn't say stop it or anything. He kind of felt flattered getting these kind of lewd pictures. One day she comes on him sexually and in the middle of it, after about a minute into it, he says, I can't do this. I just can't do this. This isn't right.

Morgan:

And

Brad:

Tries to back away. Yeah. Tries to back away from it. And then she accuses him of raping her. This is a very, very, very dangerous thing. And it's obviously hard for both people involved. It's obviously hard for the one who's in the middle of it who experienced this. I usually say the injured spouse, the one who's been betrayed, both her kind of injured in the situation, but the one who wasn't involved, the one who feels like they've been cheated on, it's really hard for them. And consequently, that makes it much harder for the one who was involved in that kind of thing.

Morgan:

So the moral of the story is if someone is sending you text messages or always be above board and talk to your spouse about everything, being open and honest is so crucial because things like this happen.

Brad:

Well, and part of what makes it hard is that person was still involved in some gray, and that makes it hard for the one who's been betrayed to really go along with the story and believe everything. They were like, whatever. Come on,

Morgan:

You were already doing something.

Brad:

And then another time, a woman who was just drugged and she was taken advantage of. And so there's things like this that happen. There are people out there that do this kind of thing, unfortunately,

Morgan:

And they prey on people too.

Brad:

Oh yeah, yeah.

Morgan:

They're looking for you to let your guard down and to,

Brad:

Yeah. And it's men and women that do this. It's women as well. It's not just men.

Morgan:

Oh, right. Yeah.

Brad:

That prey.

Morgan:

Well, there's some characteristics here. Yeah, go ahead. A few of these are sexual contact was attempted or forced on the spouse. Kind of like in your examples, the spouse may have started to be a willing participant at first, but changed their mind at some time during sexual activity. Sometimes. Usually in the beginning I would say, well, but then again, it could be in the middle.

Brad:

And lemme say this, Morgan, the spouse, they might've been willing to participate in it first and then change their mind, or they could have been not involved and forced. They could have been passive, not involved at

Speaker 6:

All.

Brad:

And because this is rare, the spouse who wasn't involved, the spouse who feels like they've been betrayed, they typically don't believe their spouse was raped or taken advantage of, which only leads to more shame for the injured spouse,

Morgan:

For

Brad:

The involved spouse.

Morgan:

Absolutely. I mean, gosh, just imagine not being believed when you've been hurt from that. Oh, it's horrible. It's horrible. Yeah.

Brad:

Yeah. It's horrible. It's ridiculous pain.

Morgan:

So both people need healing big time. And this happens like you said, with both men and women. And Brad, do you want to go on to the revenge affair?

Brad:

Yeah, the revenge affair. This is a affair that occurs after a spouse has been betrayed. They feel like they're not healing fast enough or they feel like the betrayer isn't helping them heal or they're not getting it. They're not being honest, they're not. They're continuing the deception. They're still involved in their own affair in a way. They're kind of throwing up your hands saying, you know what?

Morgan:

If you're going to do that to me,

Brad:

I'm going to do it to you.

And so they want to make the spouse who's having the affair understand the pain that they're in and to wake 'em up sometimes and to wake 'em up. And typically this occurs after several months of trying. And I've seen this typically, it's kind of almost like a last ditch effort where they're trying to get a response out of their spouse on a matter to 'em. And so typically several months after trying to recover from the affair, they feel like they're not getting answers as to why it occurred or they're not getting that person there to help them. And they're like, you know what?

Morgan:

I'm lonely. I'm tired.

Brad:

Yeah, I'm going to do this on my own. I'm tired of hurting. And so they have kind of a revenge affair. And I've seen this happen a few times where people just get so exhausted, so burned out, and they feel like they're the only one trying to make it work, that they're like, I'm going to show you what it feels like. And then they go do it. That can be difficult if you don't have a therapist who's trained in an infidelity, that can be difficult. I remember the first time I saw that the first two times I saw that that was pretty difficult because you got someone who's burned out having their own affair. Then you've got someone who, who's been caught in an affair for some time not helping their spouse heal. And then all of a sudden they feel betrayed and they're like, Hey, you just hurt me. How come? But they have

Morgan:

No ground to stand on because they also have done it

Brad:

Well. But that's what the spouse who just had the revenge affair thinks. But now that person's been hurting as well because just now you abandoned me. You're not there for me anymore. And it gets complicated because both people are hurting, both feel abandoned. The spouse who just had the revenge affairs is saying, look, you've been abandon me all this time and now you're not helping me.

Morgan:

It's kind of like that whole adage of two wrongs, don't make a right because still pain begets pain and more

Brad:

Pain. It doesn't make it right. It doesn't help. And that's a tricky type of affair because when people get into that, both are hurting both one answers. And what's really hard about this is both of them are thinking of their own pain at the moment, and it's pretty deep. So both people are caught in their own pain and it's pretty hurtful.

Morgan:

It's really hard to step back and help your spouse when you feel so abandoned and hurt. Do you want to go to the next one or you want to say anything more about, I can talk about the next one.

Brad:

Yeah, go ahead and talk about the exit affair.

Morgan:

Okay. So the exit affair is an affair that occurs because the spouse doesn't care about the future of the marriage. So they're trying to do what they can to get out. They've reached a place where they simply don't care and really about being with their spouse. They get into an affair either as a way to end the relationship with their spouse or they're very susceptible to an affair because they're really investing so little time into the marriage. And when working with this type of affair, the betrayer may experience the feelings of ambiguity that we discussed earlier in the show. But what can be helpful in rebuilding the romantic love and influencing the betrayal to stay in the marriage is finding ways to do new, different and exciting activities together. But really another thing we've said in the show too is it's important not to try to go and do a romantic candlelight dinner because that person is really thinking

Brad:

Something like

Morgan:

New, different. They're thinking, gosh, I'm not in love with you. Why are we doing this? So one person you've talked about before, they've got tickets to the basketball game and they went and did that together because it's something that they knew that their spouse would really love and it would kind of wake them up.

Brad:

And it doesn't necessarily have to be things expensive, just new and different. It releases adrenaline in the brain. That helps. The other thing that helps though is honestly getting help. There's very little hope for this person when they're leaving. That's why they cheat. That's why they do this. It's almost kind of this rubber stamp, I'm done. This is me sticking the landing, so to speak.

Morgan:

And they're often very tired and withdrawn.

Brad:

So getting professional help that helps doing those exciting activities together helps. Also. The other thing is you have to deal with the negative cycles that come up because the negative cycle is what has led the person who's having an exit affair and to be burned out, to be vulnerable enough to have an affair. And let me say this, I would say most affairs that I've seen have had elements of an exit affair,

Morgan:

Tired. They're ready to leave, they're done.

Brad:

Most affairs that I've seen have had elements of an exit affair. Let me just describe briefly the psychology of a betrayer. Not every betrayer fits this category, and we'll spend more time talking about this on a future show. But briefly, the psychology of a betrayer that you get caught into a negative cycle. This person, because they're in a negative cycle, they then become resentful. They begin to not share things as much. They begin not to express their feelings and emotions and share things as much. And so that negative cycle creates that kind of climate for that. So this person, because there's a negative cycle there, it goes on long enough, they get to a place where they're not really talking as much. They're kind of more withdrawn. So they're not sharing as much. They're not opening up as much. They're not confiding as much. That right there makes them vulnerable. Vulnerable for an affair, obviously. And then they start feeling resentful, but they got hurt that are there. They feel resentful. They feel alone, they feel sad. And then they start kind of feeling numb, maybe a little indifferent. And then they start, this is the key thing. They start caring less about the marriage. And because they're caring less, they're extremely vulnerable to an affair, to someone new,

Morgan:

To

Brad:

Someone that's there

Morgan:

That

Brad:

They can open up to, that they can open up to share human. They have to talk about something. And that's why all these different things that we've seen, they really tie in well, I think to the exit affair. Not everybody that has it is really wanting to leave the marriage, but many times you'll see that where they're just kind of burned out. And that might be a better way to describe this as the burned out affair instead of the exit affair. But what they do is they care less about the marriage. They're vulnerable to someone else, vulnerable to an affair, and then they experience it. They experience that romantic love. They experience

Morgan:

That connection,

Brad:

That connection again, and

Morgan:

The attention from another person.

Brad:

And they feel good because they've been miserable and unhappy,

Morgan:

And they can feel like they can open up to that person in a way they couldn't with their spouse.

Brad:

And here's the tricky thing too. You'll have someone who before would never have an affair, but they get worn out so much that they're vulnerable to it and they're already thinking of it, and they'll justify it in their mind, well, we're not happy. We're going to divorce. I want a divorce. I want to leave.

Brad:

Yeah, we

Brad:

Splitting up

Brad:

Anyways.

Brad:

Yeah, we're splitting up anyways. And so then they's the way they justify it. But that's kind of a common thing that you see with a lot of affairs and the psychology of the betrayer. And so you could call the exit affair, probably the burned out affair.

Morgan:

Yeah, that makes sense. And if you'd like to read a little bit more about these affairs and just more information in general, you can check out our website,

Brad:

Go to our website. We have these on there,

Morgan:

Marriage solutions tulsa.com.

Brad:

Yeah, go to the blog on our website. Check that out. You'll get a lot of this good, helpful information,

Morgan:

And you can give us a call as well and can set an appointment with one of our therapists. 9 1 8 2 8 1 60 60.

Brad:

Yep. Our practice Marriage Solutions here in Tulsa, we have one of the only group practices just dedicated to marriage counseling. This is a think tank. This is an organization where we collaborate with each other. Everybody here has advanced training. We collaborate with each other.

Morgan:

We research and have created some

Brad:

Of the best methods for working with couples, and we're a place that's just marriages only and you want to go to a place like that because getting good help with a marriage is extremely difficult,

Morgan:

And we help couples and individuals with relationship issues. For example, if your spouse is leaving you and you'd like to stop your divorce, we can help you with that. We've helped people where they've already divorced each other and they've had second thoughts. We've helped them to remarry each other through couples counseling, and so there are a lot of different issues within the relationship that we can help you with. But yes, couples premarital, already married, couples experiencing difficulty and trauma, as well as if you just want a refresher on your relationship.

Brad:

Yeah, the couples that we've helped you have been divorced, they feel like your marriage has been restored,

Not just okay, they got back together, that kind of thing, but they feel like their marriage has been restored, and that's what's amazing. That's the most important part. Thanks for listening to Healing Broken Trust. If you like this episode, you can always get our show notes and more details and links to the resources we discussed@healingbrokentrust.com. Also, as long as you're online, head on over to healing broken trust.com/retreat for details on an upcoming one-on-one retreat with me. If you like us, please subscribe and leave a review for us on iTunes. As always, everything discussed on this podcast is either my opinion or Morgan's opinion and is not to be taken as relationship advice because I'm not your therapist, nor have I considered your personal situation as your therapist. This podcast, it's for your entertainment and education only, and I really do hope you've enjoyed it. See, until next time.

Ep 22: "If You Cheat On Me I’ll Leave You” And Other Things People Say That Challenge the Conversation

Brad:

You're going to have to discuss this multiple times, and this is what people think is, gosh, we've talked about this. I've already answered that question once. I've already answered it a few times, but now we're on the 20th time. You've asked that and I've answered it and I haven't changed it. Now we're on the hundredth time. Now we're in it into the hundreds of times. But here's the thing though, with this is the injured spouse. For them to overcome the trauma and really to recover from this, you do have to go through this.

Morgan:

You are listening to Healing Broken Trust podcast with Brad and Morgan Robinson, where we talk about healing from affairs, infidelity, trust, and cheating in your relationship from the perspective of a professional marriage therapist and a fair recovery expert. If you want to save your relationship after infidelity, this podcast is for you. You've made it to episode 22 where we address the O. So important question of how do we talk about the affair. Some say it's not important to talk about the affair, that it's useless and will just make things worse, and others say you must talk about it and you can't heal without talking about it. So we're going to lay the myths to rest and talk about what really needs to happen for you to fully recover. Also, we want to hear from you and get your perspective on things. So if you want to share your thoughts or maybe you have some questions, then go on over to healing broken trust.com. Click on the tab called Weekly Calls and leave a voice message for us there. You can also download the free resources that go along with this episode@healingbrokentrust.com slash episode 22. That's episode and the number 22. And let's get started.

Brad:

This show we're talking about how to recover from an affair, the steps that need to be taken to recover the time. Basically everything that a person needs to know to work through this. We are discussing that in detail, in depth, and so you're not going to really hear this anywhere else. This is one of the big issues that people struggle with. We are here to help you guys work through this. In fact, we had an email that was sent into us that really, I think I've heard a lot from people, and I'm glad somebody sent this in. And it basically is this, Brad, how do I talk to my wife about this? She told me before I had this affair. I never want you to tell me if you've ever cheated on me. I don't want to know that because I've been betrayed by someone else before in a previous marriage.

And really to answer that question for that person, I would say most people before they're betrayed, they do not want to know any details. They would rather just not know because what I don't know is not going to hurt me. But after people know they've been betrayed and they know they've been cheated on, most people want to know in great detail about the affair. And so it's kind of different rules. Usually the person who's been betrayed, sometimes they'll say things like, I will leave you if you ever cheat on me, if you ever sleep with anybody else, I'll leave you. But after an affair, after you're really dealing with it and you're not in hypothetical situations, most people choose to stick around and try to work on it, and most people want to know about it because that's only way they find relief in healing.

In fact, only about 7% of people don't want to know anything about the affair. They don't want to talk about it. If your spouse falls into that 7% of people who don't want to know anything about it, who don't want to talk about it, you can't make them talk about it. You can't tell them anything about it. You just can't give them information. They don't want to know. And so you kind of only go as far as that injured spouse wants to know and the types of questions that they have. Hopefully that answers the listener question. Morgan, we've been talking about the ground rules on how to talk about an affair, and one of the things we said is how you talk about this, it's so much more important than really what is said. It needs to be in a climate of compassion, care, understanding. And so just to kind recap what we said is people need to schedule time to talk about this.

Morgan:

That's right. Yeah. Set aside that time and that journaling will help you to organize your thoughts and feelings so that you can make that time more productive. You talked about open limitations a little bit.

Brad:

Yeah, we talked about that a little bit last time. We're going to really get into that into detail today. The person who had the affair really needs to have a vomit session where they just get everything out and just purge. Just get it all out there, just get it all out there. And then common reaction is that people find this is not an easy process. It's like cough medicine. We talked about that. If people are talking about betrayal, they get angry, they get upset, and it's like cough medicine for both people

Morgan:

Because the medicine goes down and it's not tasty. It doesn't feel good at all.

Brad:

No, but it helps people get better.

Morgan:

The benefit is definitely seen

Brad:

Over time. And so sometimes spouses who've been betrayed, they can be very emotionally abusive, verbally abusive. And that's why we were talking about journaling as well, is just channel those emotions onto paper. And that way you're not lashing out of your spouse because they feel quite

Morgan:

Abused,

Brad:

Abused, also demotivated,

That kind of thing. The injured spouse is attacking during the discussions. You're only hurting the person who needs to be there as a healer for you. They're not going to be motivated to be there. And basically the last thing we left off with is it's important that spouse is not interrupt during the conversation. Discussing affair can get heated very quickly, and really you should try to do everything in your power not to let this happen. If you can learn just to sit and listen, not interrupt, write down questions, write down comments that you have in your journal, you're going to hear things that you may not hear. If you interrupt, you're going to hear things that you wouldn't hear if you interrupt them. And so that's what we left off is don't interrupt each other. Let the betrayer finish their thoughts, finish their sentences. If you feel like you're catching them in a lie or a white lie, really try to not interrupt them because you're not going to get all the information you need if you sit there and you pounce on them if you think you're making a mistake. And so that's kind of where we left off, Morgan. What are the other ground rules?

Morgan:

The next one really is it's important to discuss the affair in a way that gives your spouse reassurance that you're reassuring them that the affair will not happen again. And that's the most important thing. They need to know why, of course, but they also need to know this isn't going to happen again. It's not a pattern of betrayal and maybe it has in the past, but it won't go any further. So don't avoid or deny the affair or minimize the damage or fall into denial because it will only create more distrust. And that's the biggest thing is you want to create trust. And that's going to take a lot of time. If you as a betrayer find yourself becoming defensive, say to your spouse, Hey, I know I've hurt you. I want to make this better and I'm committed to the process, but I'm feeling attacked and I think we need to take a minute and breathe.

Brad:

Yeah, and Morgan, I'm glad you said that because it's so important in this process, the betrayer needs to be able to come to the injured spouse and just share everything and get it out there. And they need to get it all out

Morgan:

There and trust the process.

Brad:

They need to trust the process. But I like what you're saying. The betrayer needs to be proactive in this. They need to be the ones initiating conversations at times. They need to be proactive. They need to be

Morgan:

Open and honest. You need to take responsibility for the actions that they took, but also help your spouse by realizing that they're hurting and stop them from spiraling downward in uncontrollable anger by going to them and being open.

Brad:

And Morgan, what I like about what you just said is you're showing that important idea of I'm willing to do whatever it takes.

Most betrayers, they want to suppress information, but if you go to them and you initiate conversations about this, you go and you're willing to talk about it. You just tell them information about it. That helps the injured spouse, since they don't have to protect themselves as much, they sense you are here to help me heal. You are here to help me. I don't need to be in a self-protective mode. I don't need to keep my walls up. And so what you're saying is really important. One of the things that's really important almost as a word of caution is if you do not talk about this, if you don't discuss the affair, this is really the best way for people to recover from this is to talk about this, to deal with it upfront, to really just almost hug a cactus in a way. You just have to really deal with it. And if people are unwilling to discuss this, it results in a much slower recovery time increases the chances of divorce,

And it creates more distress. Like I said last week, the more that the injured spouse knows, the more they feel like they're healing. You do not want to fall into the trap as the betrayer of suppressing information. You feel like you're suppressing this because of your guilt. You don't want to make your spouse feel worse, but that suppressing of the information is actually causing them to feel worse, and it's going to keep you stuck in guilt longer. And suppressing information is going to keep you stuck in the fantasy of the affair, the secret of the affair, and those secrets in that fantasy. It's going to keep you from becoming emotionally invested back into the marriage and relationship the way you need to be.

And so the more you share, the more you're deconstructing that fantasy of what the affair was, and it's bringing you more into reality. You are entering the real world, you're entering into reality again, and it's helping you lose those feelings for the affair partner. And it's helping you reconnect. In fact, what it's doing is it is helping you reconnect with your spouse, but it's bringing a new level of intimacy that hasn't been there because there's a new level of honesty. You're being more open about your feelings, you're being more open about what you need from your spouse. And so that's why this step of talking about the affairs is so important.

Morgan:

Yeah, absolutely. But also the next point that we wanted to make was betrayers will need to revisit many different aspects of the affair multiple times. We've talked about that on the show quite a few times. Those obsessive or intrusive thoughts that you keep asking the same questions because you find and learn new things each time you ask the question. But discussing how they met with the affair partner once will not accomplish. It's usually more than once, typically that they'll ask the same questions, but each time it's discussed, you'll learn something new and that'll in turn help you to recover. For many couples, it does get annoying that they have to revisit the topic again and again, but involve spouses. The betrayer must maintain their composure. You must maintain your composure and let your spouse know that you're there to help them to heal and to recover. It's a huge, it's going to make a huge difference.

Brad:

And Morgan, one of the things that you said that's real important is you're going to have to discuss this multiple times, and this is what people think is, gosh, we've talked about this. I've already answered that question once. I've already answered it a few times, but now we're on the 20th time. You've asked that and I've answered it and I haven't changed it. Now we're on the hundredth time. Now we're in it into the hundreds of times. But here's the thing though, with this is the injured spouse, for them to overcome the trauma and really to recover from this, you do have to go through this. The injured spouse, it needs to be talked about. It's wrong for professional to tell somebody, look, it's been six months, it's been a year, it's been five years. Never bring it up again. That's just absurd. And it really shows a lack of understanding of the trauma recovery process for somebody from this type of particular trauma.

Morgan:

And the time that's passed, I mean, it could be two years, three years, 20 years, but pain is still there.

Brad:

Oh, yeah. Time doesn't heal

Morgan:

Anything. It's discussing it. It's talking about, it's working through it. I mean, some healing may occur, but the full healing,

Brad:

No, not the full healing. So people need to talk about it multiple times. There's different reasons why people need to talk about this multiple times or the same question multiple times. I would say the first reason is there's shattered assumptions that the injured spouse has about the betrayer. I no longer feel like I know who you are, so they're trying to reconstruct who this person is. Part of it is I just can't believe this. This has blown my mind. It's shocking. It's shocking. So just, I can't believe they said this. They did this. You're trying to reconstruct it. Another thing is it's like watching a movie like Inception. I love that movie,

But there's different layers to that plot. But every time you watch a movie like that where you talk about an affair, you're uncovering different layers of it. You're seeing something that you haven't seen before. And the more that the injured spouse can talk about this process, it, it's actually bringing healing to them. It's helping them become more complete. And you as a spouse who's had the affair, that's part of you being a healer, is really being patient with that, showing that you're willing to do whatever it takes. And it's going to take sometimes some questions literally hundreds of times to get answered. And that is frustrating, but that's part of for the maximum healing process to take place. It's going to be several times of just asking the same questions.

Morgan:

And there's one thing that you did mention earlier in one of the points that you made about the vomit session, making sure that you get it out there, get it all out. But one thing that I think ties into this that we need to probably remind people is if you don't vomit it out and new information gets in there, wedged in there where you haven't told everything, it's almost like starting over, like you've said before in the discovery process. It's a shock. So each time you discover a new layer or a new piece of information, it's like, oh my gosh. It's like going right back to the beginning of the hurt of the pain. It's pulled up, the scab has been ripped off. So it's important to get all of that information out there, but then you're still going to have those same questions over and over. But I mean, your story is the same because it's the truth. It just needs to be understood and rethought through again, probably.

Brad:

Yeah. Yeah. Morgan, you brought up another good point too, is really with the point that you made about

Morgan:

Having a vomit session, making sure

Brad:

That it's out there because when you bring it up like this and you have a vomit session or a purge session, you just get it all out and information is discovered later. That person, sometimes they feel like, gosh, I'm just starting over, or they feel like even, what else do I not know? Yeah, what else do I not know? And it keeps them hypervigilant on the defensive or wall is up.

Morgan:

And

Brad:

So that's more of the reason for you just to get everything out at once, as much as you can get it all out there. And that way they feel safer. And sometimes couples do struggle with that where, gosh, we're in this for three months or even a year and I find out something new, or even I've had some couples, five or six years later, they find out something new and it just kind of sets some, brings 'em back down on the ladder. And that's the importance of getting it all out there. And here's the thing too, I want to say about honesty is when you're honest about this, people stick around when they feel like you're being the healer and you're being honest. People do not stick around when they feel like you're being lied to. So if you're worried about, gosh, if my spouse really knows this or if they know that they're going to leave me, chances are they're probably going to stay. As long as they feel like you're being honest with them and you're transparent with them and you're really trying to rebuild things, they leave when they feel like, I'm not getting anywhere, you're not helping me.

Morgan:

And think about how light of a load you'll carry with being able to tell them everything and then getting through it and healing. I mean on your part as the betrayer as well, your conscience will thank you

Brad:

And you're going to have a lot less guilt, that kind of thing. Absolutely. There's some areas that you want to stay away from. We really advise couples to stay away from anything that makes you more obsessive. Sometimes people ask, what do I share? What kind of questions? What do I share? Do I share that I slept with this person? Do I share that on our anniversary, we did this or I did that with the affair partner?

Morgan:

How much information is too much information?

Brad:

Yeah. Well, and here's the thing, there's kind of a protocol for this. There is some things that I would strongly encourage people not to talk about that, but most of the time, whatever the injured spouse feels like they need to know. I'm okay with that. Like I said earlier, only about 7% of injured spouses have no desire for any sort of details. Two thirds want to know great details. And so the three areas are graphic, sexual details, love letters, and anything that makes the injured spouse more obsessive about the past.

Morgan:

And you want to avoid those, right? Yeah,

Brad:

You want to avoid those. And generally the obsessiveness comes from graphic sexual details and love letters

And graphic sexual details are really hard for men, especially because they'll picture their wife with another man, very visual doing certain things, and men are very visual. So it's much to overcome. And I found that people get stuck in thinking about this. Men will get stuck or even women get stuck in thinking about the sexual part because they don't have all the information. And what happens is their mind is just kind of going through all the information they know. And part of that is the sexual details because they're trying to understand what happened, why it happened. And so they're just going through all this information. And part of that's the sexual details. One of the best ways I know how for people to overcome the sexual details is really to understand the whole affair and to get all their questions answered. Because once they have everything answered, they have stopped obsessing of the unknown of the unknown, and it's just obsessing period. And that causes them to get stuck on the graphic sexual details. The other area you do not want to know is love letters. That generally is harder for women. And let me say this though, it's not just hard on women, it's hard on men too, but it's very hard to see that your spouse may be bashing you

In a letter, but praising somebody else, talking positively, someone else, giving them a nickname that you do not have, they may have a different type of relationship than you've had with your spouse. I had a guy that came in a little over a year ago. His wife had an affair last summer, and when they came in, they came in about April or March, and this was really interesting. No healing had virtually taken place because hers was an online affair with somebody in a different state, but he had all this information online and every day he looked over it, just poured over it, read everything, revisited everything. So the guy was very depressed, very obsessed, still not a lot of things made sense. And so there was no healing that took place.

Morgan:

You kind of kept him right there.

Brad:

Yeah, it kept him in the beginning of the process and nine months afterwards, he should have been in a very comfortable place, not perfect, but in a place where I definitely feel like I'm moving forward. I have hope. I know we're working through this. I've worked through a lot of the major part of this. We should have already been there. It's been nine months at ground

Morgan:

Zero,

Brad:

Nine months at a really, really bad place. You want to avoid graphic sexual details. You want to avoid love letters, text messages, emails. Unfortunately, that's how so many people find out about an affair nowadays. It's an online affair where they got kind of these text messages and smartphones and things in Facebook. That's how people find out. But you really want to try to avoid kind of bearing yourself in that and revisiting it because it's only going to keep you held hostage.

Morgan:

So one thing we have here to avoid the scenario, we recommend writing these questions down, sleep on them. Ask yourself, is this information, is it really necessary for my healing? Sometimes just writing it down will help you kind of get through those feelings, but sleep on it.

Brad:

Yeah, that's a good rule of thumb. Just give yourself some time when you get the question you want it answered right away, but give yourself some time

Morgan:

Because

Brad:

With these types of questions, they tend to be re-traumatizing. They tend to open the wound back up. They tend to pour salt on that wound and it doesn't heal. So give yourself some time. You don't need to really jump ahead into this. And I would, to be honest with you, I really encourage you not to ask questions about sexual, obviously, did you make love? Did you have sex? That kind of thing.

Morgan:

Will I need to worry

Brad:

About STDs? STDs, were they on birth control? That's fine. But things like sexual positions, lingerie you really need to avoid. And there's some more graphic questions that you could ask that I don't want to say, but you really want to avoid that because it just keeps you stuck.

Morgan:

Yeah,

Brad:

It retraumatizes you.

Morgan:

So Brad, we are going to out of time here very soon, but would you like to talk about the open limitations?

Brad:

Let say, let me just summarize the last two steps here. When discussing an affair, it's important to do what we call open limitations. Where as time goes on, you're probably talking about the affair for hours on length, especially in the early weeks. You're talking about the affair constantly. But as time goes on, that idea of open limitations is at any moment the injured spouse is able to bring up a question and it's discussed for no longer than 15 to 30 minutes. And part of that is because the longer you go on, the more that's shared, the more that's told can cause people to get angry

Morgan:

Escalation.

Brad:

And if it's not done, you get into that negative cycle of blame, withdraw, one person's blame and the other one's withdrawing. But if you do that, that tends to be the best way to do this. It's just discuss it for no more than 15 to 30 minutes and it helps people really begin to recover and you're just kind of doing it throughout your

Morgan:

Day. And if you do the journal method, like what we had talked about in the last show, if you write it down and you really think through, okay, what do I need to know? What questions do I have? You're going to make those conversations within 15 to 30 minutes. You're going to make them more productive. You're going to get somewhere instead of falling into just a big argument.

Brad:

Yeah, exactly. Just limit yourself to 15 to 30 minutes per question or part time that you discuss this, and you can talk about it really at any time. Obviously not when the kids are around, but really at any time. So the injured spouse has the freedom to ask this really at any time they feel the need to, but you're not discussing it at length. You're able to kind of resume your normal life together

Morgan:

And 30 minutes wraps up and then you're able to go and cool down and really

Brad:

Breathe. And then kind of the next thing is because the betrayer many times feels like this is hopeless, I can't help this person heal. I can't be forgiven. And I notice people when they've dealt with the affair for a long periods of time, like a year or more, they start feeling like, gosh, nothing I can do is going to have any effect on this person. And so this is where that care and compassion comes in. Is what you are doing really helps me,

Us talking about this? You don't understand how much this helps me. I appreciate this. I notice what you're doing. I notice what you're contributing, praising them for what you're getting because it's only going to help them give you more. And so that's important, and that is many times the injured spouse feels like I don't owe them anything, have a huge wall up. That is true and that needs to be worked on, but I can understand where you're coming from. I'm not saying that's necessarily true that you shouldn't try to help them, but if you give them appreciation, give them positive feedback. I notice what you're doing. These small things matter. These things that you're doing matter, they're going to have more motivation and sometimes they're just completely demoralized

Morgan:

And ultimately you will get the healing that you need as the betrayed spouse. So it's a win-win situation. One person feels like they can be open and honest and sharing, and then you also get the healing that you need, the answers that you need.

Brad:

Thanks for listening to Healing Broken Trust. If you like this episode, you can always get our show notes and more details and to the resources we discussed at healingbrokentrust.com. Also, as long as you're online, head on over to healing broken trust.com/retreat for details on an upcoming one-on-one retreat with me. If you like us, please subscribe and leave a review for us on iTunes. As always, everything discussed on this podcast is either my opinion or Morgan's opinion and is not to be taken as relationship advice because I'm not your therapist, nor have I considered your personal situation as your therapist. This podcast is for your entertainment and education only, and I really do hope you've enjoyed it. See you Until next time.

Ep 23: How Can We Forgive and Be Forgiven? Should I stay with someone who hurts me?

Morgan:

We've heard that a lot of people say before something like this happens to them, if ever they cheat on me or I'm going to be gone, there's no way that we could work on this. But the truth is, when it actually happens to you,

Brad:

You don't know.

Morgan:

You just don't know. And most of the time people want to work on it. Most of the time, people want to heal and try to rebuild the relationship. You are listening to Healing Broken Trust podcast with Brad and Morgan Robinson, where we talk about healing from affairs, infidelity, trust, and cheating in your relationship from the perspective of a professional marriage therapist and a fair recovery expert. If you want to save your relationship after infidelity, this podcast is for you. In episode 23, we're talking about how we can forgive and be forgiven. So many people want to jump straight to forgiveness without really healing from the betrayal or earning trust, and they make it so much harder to fully experience forgiveness. So we get into such a hurry to stop feeling the pain and get back to normal that we fall into the temptation of saying, do you forgive me? Yes. Great. Now stop talking about the affair. But as you may have discovered as you listen to this podcast, that that just won't work. So make sure you go and download the free resources@healingbrokentrust.com slash episode 23, and let's talk about how to forgive and be forgiven.

Today we're talking about forgiveness, right, Brad? And we're going to talk about what is forgiveness and kind of some of the myths associated with forgiving your spouse after infidelity.

Brad:

Yes,

Morgan:

Brad, you want to start talking about what is forgiveness?

Brad:

Yeah, forgiveness is something that many people claim to believe in, but when it actually comes time to forgiving, it's very hard to do. Sometimes couples struggle with forgiveness. They have a struggle feeling like they're forgiven, especially if they've cheated. I've had couples frequently after they've had an affair, come to counseling and feel hopeless that they can't repair the marriage, but they don't realize that some of the forgiveness has already taken place. Just the fact that you're in marriage counseling, your spouse is willing to work on you. Maybe it's not 100% complete forgiveness, but it shows you that they're willing to forgive

Morgan:

And work

Brad:

On the relationship and work on the relationship. And there is some forgiveness that's taken place just to get that far.

Morgan:

Yeah, we've heard that a lot of people say before something like this happens to them, if ever they cheat on me or I'm going to be gone, there's no way that we could work on this. But the truth is, when it actually happens to you,

Brad:

You don't know.

Morgan:

You just don't know. And most of the time, people want to work on it, and most of the time people want to heal and try to rebuild the relationship. Wouldn't you agree?

Brad:

Yeah, they do. And you don't know what you're going to do until it happens to you. One of the things that's important to know about forgiveness, it's not about forgetting or exposing yourself to be hurt again, it's about being able to move forward without living in the past. Truly about healing from the pain is what Forgiveness is an important thing for spouses who've been betrayed by an affair. Forgiving your partner for cheating on you doesn't necessarily mean you have to restore the relationship. It doesn't mean reconciliation. It just means you can let go of your need to punish your spouse for what they did to you. But one of the misconceptions about forgiveness is the false belief that forgiveness is the same as saying everything is okay between us. It's no big deal. I forgive you. Forgiveness is not giving permission for the affair to continue. Injured spouses cannot truly forgive until they're safe from being hurt. Further, forgiveness is something that betrayed spouses do based on their own inner strength, rather than the betrayers

Morgan:

Doing what they've done.

Brad:

Yeah, that's a good way to put it. Rather than the betrayer actions or remorse, it's obviously very hard to forgive when you've repeatedly betrayed and cheated on. And we're going to get into different types of forgiveness. Forgiveness that we're talking about here is really about letting go of the pain and letting go of them hurting you further. But there's another type of forgiveness if you are going to be able to reconcile and try to make things work. It's forgiveness that where you really let that person in. And we're going to talk about that later as well.

Morgan:

So there's two types of forgiveness. One, when that spouse is not around, maybe they left you for another person. And then one part of a different type of forgiveness is when you want to reconcile the relationship.

Brad:

And here's the key difference. One is about letting go of resentment and hurt. You can do that whether you're with them or if you're not with them. And then the second type of forgiveness is it's more than just letting go of the resentment and hurt and the need to punish them. It's about letting yourself be vulnerable and depend on that person. Again, you have to trust them and to trust them, and that's a different type of forgiveness that we're going to discuss as well. How to attain.

Morgan:

So do we want to talk about the myths of

Brad:

Forgiveness

Morgan:

Now? Yeah.

Brad:

Sometimes people falsely believe forgiving means I'm weak. I think kind of like my response to that is really, I think it's actually a sign of strength.

Morgan:

Yeah, definitely.

Brad:

You can let go of the pain of someone betraying you and hurting you, and you think that's weakness. It's a sign of strength and it's a sign of maturity as well.

Morgan:

And then that kind of plays with the idea that people think, well, if I forgive, that means I'm forgetting and I'm condoning. But that's not the case at all. If real forgiveness, the right forgiveness, it's standing up for yourself, but it's also standing up for your relationship. And then it's also, it's fully healing and not necessarily letting that happen again. So the second one, if I don't make her pay for the affair, it will happen again. Speaking of happening again.

Brad:

And that's a common myth that people have. If I don't make my spouse pay for it, they're going to do it again.

Morgan:

So I have to punish them. But actually making the betrayer suffer causes doubt that the relationship can actually recover. Injured spouses need their partners to help them heal and to be there for them. But if they make their betrayal's life difficult, it will be much harder for them to heal and be hopeful that the relationship can recover. So it would be quite discouraging if you're constantly needing to make them pay for it.

Brad:

Oh yeah. Because here's the thing, the one who was involved, sometimes people who have affairs many times are burned out. They have issues with the marriage, why they do this, and understandably, you're upset and you're hurting, you're hurting a great deal. But just to punish them consistently and constantly for it. Lemme say this, there's a difference between questions, asking things and needing them, needing reassurance, and you're needing questions answered and you want to talk about it. I don't look at that as punishing them, but making them crawl on glass, making them do all the sacrifice, all this stuff because they betrayed you. And that may work in the short term, but long term marriage wise, that is a recipe for disaster. And that creates a very hopeless feeling in the person who had the affair because they don't feel like you guys can ever move forward and move past it

Morgan:

And sacrificing. I mean, there's going to be some of that with making sure that they come home early. Oh, sure. Yeah, definitely.

Brad:

To rebuild trust, be transparent and honest. Yeah, that's standard stuff. But I'm talking about this punishing type thing. You're their parent again, and it's kind of this extreme,

Morgan:

You can't have your car. I'm not going to let you have your car.

Brad:

Well, they lose all rights. That just doesn't work, not long term. And understandably, they may go along with that short term, but you can't build a marriage on that. It's not something that you can build a marriage with. There's not equality, there's not respect. It makes it very, very difficult.

Morgan:

Gotcha. You want to do the third one?

Brad:

Yeah. So the third myth is my anger lets him know him or her know they can't hurt me without consequences. And that's important. People think, you know what? I'm getting angry. There's going to be consequences to this. It's actually easier for people to identify the hurts and heal them when they let go of the hurt and hatred. You can actually begin to heal when you let go of that hurt and hatred that creates that anger. And we've often talked about a key component of a fair recovery is having the betrayer there in a nurturing, supportive role. And with unforgiveness and this kind of under unforgiveness where it's resentment and hatred and anger, it really keeps that person distant. We talked about negative cycles. This is a great way to get stuck in a negative cycle.

Morgan:

Anger, yelling, hatred that way, and then the betrayer becomes distant at some point, and then it's this negative round and around cycle. Interesting. And that anger really hurts the person who's been betrayed too, because they're holding onto that. It's kind of eaten them.

Brad:

It does. Yeah, definitely

Morgan:

Does. Okay, so then the next one, forgiving her or him will make them think she didn't hurt me. Injured spouses can articulate the impact of the injury and still be able to get the feelings of hatred out of their system. So that's a myth that forgiving them will make them think they didn't hurt you.

Brad:

And what we're talking about here is you think you're saying, I'm not hurting if you say I forgive you.

Morgan:

And that's not the truth.

Brad:

That's not the truth at all. Right? And there's kind of a pattern here in what we're talking about. There's this theme of punishment. I'm holding this over your head. I'm not letting you go on from this. I'm stuck in the past and I'm going to make you be stuck in the past with me. And that's kind of the theme here. And when that happens, people commonly believe, if I forgive this,

Morgan:

You're

Brad:

Going to forget about my pain and you're going to go on and you're not going to be here with me. And that's false.

Morgan:

And I think a lot of times that would be from kind the misnomer, the incorrect thoughts about forgiveness that, oh, I have to be okay. I have to just not cry because forgiveness means I show no sadness or remorse about what happened because I'm not bothered. I'm forgiven, I forgive them. But that's not it at all. Forgiveness still runs its course. I mean, the pain still runs its course, and you still have to heal from that. So forgiveness doesn't mean that you just, well, I'm not going to cry and everything's fine.

Brad:

Well, forgiveness is a process,

Morgan:

Right?

Brad:

It's not an overnight thing, it's a process. Commonly people look at forgiveness as a light switch. I forgive you. And all of a sudden the resentment's gone. In fact, you're going to have to forgive a lot. You're going to have to forgive every day. Every day. You're going to have to choose to forgive every day, and you're going to have to choose to forgive individual aspects of the affair. You're going to have to forgive about the deception. You're going to have to forgive about any physical involvement, emotional involvement. You're going to have to forgive these specific incidences that happened

Morgan:

Kind of one thing at a time, it seems like. So we talk about forgiveness. Well, we're talking about the myths of surrounding forgiveness.

Brad:

Yeah. Commonly held beliefs that are actually false after an affair. The next one, Morgan number five is forgiveness. Commonly people falsely believe forgiveness means I approve of my spouse's immoral behavior. So people look at forgiveness, meaning approval. But this is important to understand that when spouses are cheated on, they do have a right to condemn that behavior. And at the same time, they need to release ill will towards the involved spouse,

Morgan:

Which takes time.

Brad:

And here's the thing, ill releasing, ill will does not mean automatically letting them back in your life to be hurt again. It just means you're letting yourself go. You're letting yourself off the hook to punish them. And also for spouses who've been betrayed, you can still believe in right and wrong and stand up for yourself without giving in or lowering your guard. That's not what forgiveness means. Forgiveness says, I'm letting go of the resentment, but I'm still keeping my boundaries. I'm not going to let you hurt me again.

Morgan:

And I think it's interesting you say you let yourself off the hook. You don't have to be the judge, jury, and executioner.

Brad:

As we get into this more, we're going to discuss actually how it affects a person physically interesting with unforgiveness, how it affects a person's heart, their immune system. It's really a cancer of the mind, you could say a cancer of the soul. And so these kinds of beliefs, they're very common. They're very popular once people have been betrayed. But here's the kicker,

They actually hold a couple up from being able to recover because like we've talked about before with negative cycles, unforgiveness, let me be careful on how I explain this, because there's different types of unforgiveness. There's the unforgiveness. Like I said earlier, I'm letting go of my resentment and hurt. We have to have that. You need to do that. I'm letting go of my own resentment and hurt and my need to punish you. Again, that's a process that you need to be working towards. And if you're listening to this, and it's been probably in the first two months of discovery, it may be hard to do that. Definitely the closer you are to when you discover it or when you find more deception from your spouse, it'll be very hard to forgive. You need to let go of that resentment, that bitterness, you're really doing it for yourself. And here's the other thing though, Morgan forgiveness, that's not letting that person back in. That's a different type of forgiveness.

Morgan:

The other type of forgiveness,

Brad:

You're talking about being vulnerable,

Morgan:

Being vulnerable,

Brad:

Letting your walls down, letting your guard down with them. We're not saying everybody has to do that. You do want to have that if you're going to have a strong marriage. But I would say regardless of what's happened, you do want to find a place of forgiveness. And it's because you're doing it for yourself. And that'll become more clear as we talk about this.

Morgan:

Gotcha. And the next one, talking about number six, this is very common. People think about this when they think of forgiveness, but one myth, forgiving means forgetting. And many people who experience an affair commonly believe the myth that they have to forget the affair in order to forgive what happened. But forgiveness actually helps them release negative feelings about the affair. Remembering the affair helps them take precautions in the future.

Brad:

That's important.

Morgan:

Yeah,

Brad:

Because you cannot forget something as painful as an affair. You're just not going to, and that's foolish to even think or suggest that you could forget about it,

Morgan:

But it just won't be in your mind all the time pressing for your attention.

Brad:

But what you do need to do is forgive for yourself. Let go of that resentment. It will help you emotionally. It'll help you move on with your life. It'll help you release baggage. It'll help you get out of the negative cycle if you do choose to recover from the affair with your spouse or your partner who had the affair. But one of the things that people commonly think is it should never be brought up again. I've been betrayed. Why can't I quit thinking about this? Why can't I quit talking about it? And that's trauma. Those are trauma symptoms. You obsess about it. You have nightmares about it. You think about it. Your stomach is full of anxiety,

Morgan:

Constantly ask the same questions over and over. And I've heard some people say, well, I can't seem to get over this. I can't seem to stop thinking about it and talking about it and asking questions about it. And my spouse thinks I'm crazy, and they're telling them they're crazy. And

Brad:

That's trauma we've talked about. That's trauma. There's trauma symptoms there,

Morgan:

But they're not crazy. The point

Brad:

Is not, no, they're not crazy. It's like somebody, it's like this Morgan. It's like if we went, me and you went on a safari in Africa, and the guy driving the Jeep on the safari was the only local, the only one that knew how to deal with wild animals. And we get attacked, and he's the only one with a phone that actually gets reception on the safari. So he's dead and the phone's gone. And it's me and you out in the jungle trying to survive. We're going to have symptoms of trauma. We're going to have anxiety. We're going to have difficulty sleeping. We're going to be obsessed about survival. We're going to be hypervigilant looking for any sign of danger and trouble. What's going on When someone's betrayed, they're not crazy. They've just been attacked and their system and their nervous system is on high alert and they're saying, okay, I got to figure out how to survive here. It's just like if we were in the jungle and we got

Morgan:

Attacked by a lion,

Brad:

By attacked by a lion, and we're trying to survive. It's the same symptoms. It's the same survival strategy that our body goes through. Interesting. And that's what happens when someone's betrayed. You're not nuts. You're not crazy. Your body's going through that and you keep asking the same questions because you want to know. That's the dangerous thing is the deception. I've only had one person tell me that the only thing that hurt more than the deception was actually the rejection. And everybody else has said it's the deception that hurts more. That's why the questions are so important is I've got to figure this out. I got to know why this happened. I got to protect myself from this again.

Brad:

And

Brad:

That's like us being in a jungle and trying to survive out in the wilderness when we know there's wild animals out there. It's the same physical thing. It's the same mental reaction. And that's called survival. That's called normal. That's called in a sense, even healthy to have that kind of response. That's your body's taken over and you're trying to protect yourself.

Morgan:

Yeah, definitely. Well, that's fantastic. That's a great way to put that picture in your mind to understand it better. And the next one,

Brad:

This myth says, this is what commonly people say is, if I forgive, I'll have to trust that person again. To a certain extent, that's true. But if I forgive, I'll have to trust that person again,

Morgan:

If you even decide to stay with your spouse.

Brad:

And here's the thing, trust is built over time, but it is really about the RA spouse believing he or she can rely on the betrayer to be there for support. Forgiveness is still something that can be accomplished even if a person is unable to rebuild trust. And that one, I would say part of that's true. I need to differentiate that you need to be able to trust them. If you can be vulnerable with them, if you can get the forgiveness where you can be vulnerable, you're going to have to be able to trust that person. You're going to have to find that you can depend on them to be vulnerable. But if you don't feel like you can trust them, you can't be vulnerable with them opening yourself up for attack. It's like, if I don't trust that lion, it's not going to eat me. I'm going to keep hiding in the safari out in the wilderness.

Morgan:

Well keep a distance.

Brad:

You don't have to be able to trust them to let go of the resentment and the hatred. That type of forgiveness, that's important too. So I want to draw a distinction there,

Morgan:

But to be close again, to have intimacy and to have a close relationship with your spouse, again, trust is going to

Brad:

Yeah, you to have that trust. Yeah. It'll be impossible to open yourself up

Morgan:

And be vulnerable

Brad:

And be vulnerable without trust.

Morgan:

Gotcha. And that does take years sometimes.

Brad:

Well, would you say it depends. It really depends. It depends on a lot of key factors, like the amount of deception, the length of the affair, what the quality of the marriage was before,

Morgan:

How open and honest, right upfront in the beginning.

Brad:

Yeah, how the negative cycles affecting them. Like you said, how open and honest the betrayer is immediately after the affair.

Morgan:

How good of a relationship they had before the affair possibly.

Brad:

Yeah. Yeah. That's a key one. That's a key one.

Morgan:

Okay, so the next one, number eight. The eighth myth. An affair is unforgivable. Okay. Something that needs to be understood about forgiveness is that it really, it's really about the internal state of the injured spouse. The injured spouse has power over the act and the involved spouse because he or she's able to say the affair is disgusting and horrible. Nevertheless, I forgive you, they're in control and not a victim of circumstances. So do you want to unpack that a little bit, Brett?

Brad:

Yeah. Here's the key thing. You as the injured spouse, you have power over the act of the affair because you're not a victim of circumstances.

Morgan:

You have more control and more power than you think. A lot of times you feel so powerless when this has happened to you.

Brad:

Well, you're not a victim, period. Obviously this is a horrible, horrible, disgusting thing. But you're more than that. And to think your life is

Morgan:

A summation of one event,

Brad:

Circumstances. I mean, you're just blown and tossed by the wind if that's all you think. It's a horrible place to live to let your circumstances dictate how you feel. And we all go through that from time to time, especially when big things like this happen. After some of the trauma starts wearing off, you're going to have to start picking yourself up and realizing at a certain point in time, I'm not going to put a timeframe on that. You're going to have to realize I'm more than my circumstances. I'm not going to be a victim of this. I'm in control over this. I'm the maker of my own destiny.

Morgan:

Something you said earlier too, forgiveness is for you just as much as it is for them, if not more.

Brad:

Yeah. It's more for you.

Morgan:

Yeah. It's for you to not let it eat you up inside.

Brad:

Yep. It's you being able to say, I'm moving on past this. Number nine is cheater is all bad and deserving of my resentment. That's very common. This person has no good qualities. Individuals who cheat on their spouse, they're human, they're weak. Many times they're in pain, and often they're not in their right mind. They feel guilty for what they've done. They feel deeply ashamed for what they've done. And here's the important thing with life. Life has a way of punishing people for their mistakes and their sins. Injured spouses. Let me ask you a serious question. Have you ever considered that you don't need to take any responsibility for setting them straight?

Morgan:

Life will do it for 'em. Yeah.

Brad:

Yeah. Life will do it.

Morgan:

Whether it's a venereal disease or just a unhappy,

Brad:

Yeah, because that need to punish life will take care of, we often create our own misfortunes. The 10th myth is getting even will help me get over the affair. That is bull crap. We talked about last time the revenge affair and how people get into affair because they've been betrayed and they're not healing well. That's the key moment of unforgiveness.

Morgan:

It's kind of like, you hurt me, so I'm going to hurt myself too.

Brad:

And that's what people do. They think they're hurting their spouse, but getting even does not replace what has been taken from you. Having your own affair doesn't help you get over the hurt and trauma that you've been experiencing.

And so that's really key. Just quickly talk about what is forgiveness, and basically we're talking about forgiveness in the context of recovering from an affair, recovering from betrayal. And so what we're talking about is really in that context. One of the truths about forgiveness that's not a myth is that forgiveness is really something that people do for themselves, forgiving you up from the anguish and burdens of the past so that the past doesn't intrude into the future. Forgiveness is a choice. It's something that is produced only with intentional effort, something that you have to choose to do. We're going to talk a little bit later about things that keep us from being able to forgive, but it's really a choice. And I do want to say this though, that for people who choose to try to work it out with the one who had the affair, the one who betrayed them, some forgiveness has taken place. We talked about how there's two different types of forgiveness that we're kind of talking about. And I want to differentiate that there's the type of forgiveness that we're mainly talking about right now. That's the forgiveness, that's letting go of the need to punish, letting go of the need for revenge

Brad:

When

Brad:

You've been betrayed and that holds onto that resentment. And you can forgive and let go of that need to punish and the need for revenge. Letting go of that resentment, that bitterness.

Morgan:

Yeah.

Brad:

Because that's

Morgan:

Going to really help

Brad:

You

Morgan:

To heal.

Brad:

Yeah. That's going to help you heal. And you're doing that for yourself.

And then there's a different type of forgiveness. And just for the lack of, I guess the English language, there's another type of forgiveness that we're going to get into later, which is really about letting that person back into your life. And so as we talk about this, I want to be real clear to be able to differentiate those two different types of forgiveness. And what we're talking about in the show right now is the forgiveness where you're letting go of the resentment, the bitterness, the need to punish, the need to punish the need for revenge

Morgan:

So it doesn't eat you alive on the

Brad:

Inside. Yeah. It doesn't eat you alive. And if you have this kind of forgiveness doesn't necessarily mean that you're letting that person back in either or that you can't. And some of that's based on them being that person that you're forgiving being safe. They have to be safe for you to be able to let them back in your life. You can't just be a doormat and say, accept you

Brad:

Blindly.

Brad:

And there's some confusion about that. While I'm on this, I want to talk about another myth about forgiveness that we didn't mention last week is that forgiveness is in a process, not

Morgan:

Just an event.

Brad:

Yeah. It's a process. It's not an event. This process stops and has starts to it in large part. It's based on how much discomfort or pain you're in. When you're in a lot of pain, it's really hard to let go of anger, resentment, and bitterness. And it's also hard, of course, to let that person in.

Morgan:

So it's not like a one time event where you're just like, no, it's not like, oh, today you hurt me. Tomorrow I have forgiven and I'm now okay. And

Brad:

It's not like that. Yeah, it's not like that at all. And here's something I want to say about this too, is when people have been betrayed, like this amount of pain is so hurtful. It's pretty intense. It's very intense. Sometimes people clinging to their resentment and their bitterness and these hard feelings as a way to really protect themselves. They get angry as a way to have boundaries and enforce those boundaries. And forgiving is a process that's going to have to happen multiple times. You're going to have to let go of that resentment multiple times. I had a couple in my office recently, and the husband was saying, well, you forgave me. Why are you talking about the affair? Why are you bringing it up? You already forgave me. What he doesn't understand is it's going to come up a lot. This is such a hurtful thing. There still has to be healing. And that doesn't mean there isn't

Morgan:

Forgiveness

Brad:

And he doesn't understand forgiveness and he doesn't understand the process either of healing from this kind of thing. And one of the things I do want to say about this quickly is with forgiveness, I want to be real clear on this, is when you do forgive, there has to be safety there. There has to be security there

Morgan:

Knowing that the affair won't happen again

Brad:

Or it's hard to let go of that anger and that bitterness. And it's really hard to do, honestly. It's really hard to forgive early on immediately after discovery. It's hard for most people. Some people will say, I forgive you and let it go. Other people are going to have a much harder time because they're in so much pain themselves. And to kind of get to that ultimate forgiveness where you're really able to let the anger and the resentment and the bitterness go, you're looking at being out of the negative cycle, getting out of that when you talk about the affair, some healing has to take place for you to really let go of all of that.

Morgan:

And sometimes that is talking about it, right? Just depends on the person and kind of the situation

Brad:

Depends on a lot of different factors. But forgiveness is a choice and it's made easier to accomplish when you have the person who has betrayed you, who's there, and they're remorseful and they're trying to help you heal. And one of the things too, Morgan, I just want to mention is forgiveness is a process where some people will go to church or leave counseling and they'll say, I'm going to forgive. And they make a decision to really forgive and they feel better about it. But then something happens and they get reminded of again, or they feel like their spouse isn't being honest again, and the pain comes back and resentment comes back, the anger comes back and they have to work through it again.

Morgan:

And sometimes they feel discouraged about that, but don't feel discouraged if that's a process, because yes, it's a process.

Brad:

It's a process that has mountains and valleys to it, kind of waves that come in and out,

Morgan:

Good days and bad

Brad:

Days. And that's how the process is. And just know this, that if you're working through this with your spouse, chances are that they have probably started that process of forgiving you, just the fact that they're listening to this program with you or going to counseling with you

Morgan:

If you're talking to the betrayer, right?

Brad:

Yeah. Right. So just wanted to say all that. Part of this is when the betrayed spouse feels safe and secure and that the affair won't happen again, they begin to let go of the need to punish or seek revenge. They begin to let go of that bitterness on the one who had the affair. They let go of that need to punish because the bleeding has stopped and the healing can begin, and they don't want to have to punish. And some of that is stuff that they do to protect themselves. That's why it's hard to be vulnerable with that person when you feel like you have to protect yourself. And so for a couple to heal, the injured spouse needs to see that remorse from the spouse who had the affair. And that's hard to give when you're caught in a negative cycle, when you're fighting and arguing, they really need to see your tears, your shame, your guilt, your disappointment in yourself, even if you don't like yourself, you hate yourself for what you did. Those are things that people tend to hide and shy away from because there's so much shame there. But they really need to see your remorse. They need to see that you're in pain so they can begin to heal.

Morgan:

Can you briefly give just what a typical negative cycle would look like for a couple? Yeah.

Brad:

I'll remind couples betrayed. Yeah. Typically the one who has been betrayed their primary emotion when they've been betrayed. Obviously there's sadness there. There's feelings of inadequacy, but I would say it's probably fear. It's almost how do I know this won't happen again? And so everything they're doing is meant to protect themselves from getting hurt further. And that could be being obsessive questioning, lack of sleep. It's all this, it's almost like, and I've talked about this before with people in our office, couples in our office. It's like if you had gone on a safari and it's just you as a couple and then the driver, and he's the only one that has a phone that gets reception, he's got a satellite phone and he gets attacked by a wild animal, a wild lion.

And it's just you and your spouse that are left to survive and you don't know where you're at and you're miles away from any civilization or help, you're going to have symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder. And that's what the person who's been betrayed has. They have the obsessiveness. They're not sleeping very well, they're running through things in their head. They're very hypervigilant, they're very alert. They use anger as a way to make themselves feel more powerful, to take control of a desperate hard situation. And those are the same things like being stranded in the wild, fearing death that happens when someone's been betrayed. They're fearing the pain of betrayal again. So they're doing those things to protect themselves.

Morgan:

So while that portrayed partner is hypervigilant, obsessive thoughts, obsessive questions that causes the betrayer to do what?

Brad:

Yeah. And see, part of that is it causes the betrayer to shut down. And they start to think, well, crud, I don't want to make this worse. I don't want to do things to make this harder on myself or harder on them. I just want us to be able to put this behind us. And so they start to do things that minimize where the betrayed spouse is coming from. And they're also really afraid and they're also very sad,

Brad:

But

Brad:

They're also very shameful. And so they want to forget about it. They don't want to discuss it anymore. And those are some things that really keep couples from being able to work through it is that shame that's there. The action tendency with shame is

Morgan:

Pull

Brad:

Away, pull away to withdraw, to hide

Morgan:

Maybe to get a little depressed about it, feel bad about themselves in the situation,

Brad:

Hopelessness. They feel hopeless. They want to get away from it. And part of that, what happens is, is they feel so horrible and they feel so bad that they begin to no longer talk about it. They no longer show any emotion about it. Sometimes they leave, sometimes they leave. If they're very, very, very shameful, feel very guilty, they'll hide. They'll leave.

Morgan:

They might say, you don't deserve what I've done to you. Things like that.

Brad:

Yeah, they do. Their shame is really, yeah, they feel very hopeless as well.

Morgan:

But

Brad:

What happens is with this negative cycle is it makes it hard. You get stuck in gridlock. You almost get into what's been called absorbing emotional states. That's rigid patterns of interaction. It's almost like it's this very robotic, almost predictable interactions. Nothing can change. It can influence until you begin to talk about some of these deeper emotions that are there.

Morgan:

So when we talk about this negative cycle that people get into,

Our goal is to change this dance. It's a dance that whenever you go into when you've been betrayed or you are the betrayer, it's just this pattern, this cycle that happens. And so when he says negative cycles, he's talking about beginning to, for the betrayer to start to engage and be open and honest and forthright and to know what to expect. They're going to probably have obsessive questions and thoughts. And so to have an idea that that's what's going to happen, possibly, that they can feel more confident and open to be able to discuss the affair. And so then that betrayed partner who has just these obsessive thoughts and hypervigilance, maybe they're able to put down their weapons for a little bit to break out of this negative cycle. And so as people are educated about what's happening and what's going on, it's going to make this process of forgiveness a lot easier. Is that basically what we're saying? Yeah,

Brad:

I'm saying that, but one of the key components, and this is unfortunately for my research of reading into affairs, in my opinion, there's not really a lot that's done to address negative cycles. You can read it a million books, but nobody really talks about the negative cycle that couples get into that led to this. And that happens when people are discussing it. You'll get information about limit your time talking about it, and that's helpful. They will give you information on how to talk about it, but they don't really ever discuss the negative cycle that happens around it. Because if you don't deal with that negative cycle that happens around discussing an affair, you're not going to make very much progress in healing. And so some of these things that we're talking about, we're talking about the need to be honest, the need to be transparent, the need to be loving and supportive, and to have goodwill and to do these things. And we're talking about right now forgiveness. That's hard when you get caught in that negative cycle

Morgan:

And the negative patterns of communicating about it and viewing it and seeing it

Brad:

And

Morgan:

Discussing it, feeling about

Brad:

It. And so lemme just say this, getting out of that negative cycle there is obviously seeing a counselor who knows what they're doing, who knows what they're doing that works with affairs, that's a good start, but also a counselor that works within the framework of emotionally focused couples therapy. Where we live, we practice here in Tulsa. I'll say this, I don't know how many people actually use that theory. There's only three people in Tulsa that I'm aware of that have advanced training and they all work in our office. And so what we're doing is it's really revolutionary. We're using the best methods. We group practice that just focuses on this, but not just we focus on marriage counseling. We're using the best method. That's actually empirically validated by research. There's other leading methods within marriage counseling that I'll say some names, Imago Gottman. Gottman has research behind his, but it hasn't been proven to work

Morgan:

And actually helped people in

Brad:

Conflict. He hasn't released any studies on it. And that's a shame because he's a marital researcher

And he's had his theory around for at least 10 years, maybe 15 years or longer, emotionally focused couples therapy has dozens of studies done on it. And one of the things about it is couples move from distress to closeness in about five month period, 75% of them and within five months have moved from distress, horrible place to a place of intimacy. But anyway, you got to deal with the negative cycle. If you have a therapist that works with emotionally focused couples therapy, if you're listening to this and Tulsa, if you're listening to this somewhere else, find somebody that uses emotionally focused couples therapy, they're going to help you deal with that negative cycle you get into,

Morgan:

You're

Brad:

Going to get better care, that you're going to get better care. I want to wrap up talking about what is forgiveness first? Go ahead. I want to finish that. We kind of got sidetracked on the negative cycle, which was important because it's important. Not everybody kind of was able to listen to our show on a regular basis. So sometimes we don't always come back to other topics. But for a couple to heal, I want to repeat this. The injured spouse needs to see the remorse of the spouse who had the affair and negative cycles keep couples from being able to have that kind of emotion and remorse. I would say in my work, maybe one out of 20 actually kind of do everything the way I would like 'em to do it. So they really need guidance. They really need help. When the spouse who's been betrayed, the injured spouse sees that their partner is living with the guilt and shame for what they did, they're living in that pain. Only then can forgiveness begin to take place.

Morgan:

And I really think it's because when that person who's betrayed their spouse feels that pain and emotion, then it's almost like the person who's been betrayed is able to relate with them better because they know each other's pain and the hurt that's behind

Brad:

It. Well, it's of like they're safe again. You get me. It's like you see this lion get me. You figure out the lion's a vegetarian and you're out in the wilderness again. And you realize, okay, he's a vegetarian. He doesn't like human. Then you feel safe walking around the lion. He likes plants. You might not come up and pet the lion or anything like that, but you're not going to be scared of the lion. And so when you see that pain, that remorse, and here's the key, you need to see that they're hurting

Morgan:

Because

Brad:

They hurt me.

Morgan:

They're

Brad:

Not hurting because the affair is over.

Morgan:

That's right.

Brad:

Big. That's a big point. And that's really important. They're hurting because they hurt me. Not that the affair, they lost the affair partner or because they're disgrace. They got caught. Yeah, they got caught or they're in disgrace or that kind of thing.

Brad:

You

Brad:

Need to see that they're hurting because they hurt me and they care about me. And once that happens, and once it's not just in a one-time event, it can be, but usually it needs to take place more often because there needs to be a lot of reassurance. So the one who's been hurt needs to see that.

Brad:

And

Brad:

This is also an important factor, why the negative cycle needs to be looked at and examined many times before couples kind of delve into the affair recovery process. And I say that because you get caught in that negative cycle. You can't do this,

Brad:

You

Brad:

Can't heal, you can't do this. And many times, honestly, there's factors where people have affairs, there's things that go into that. And we've talked about how

Morgan:

Kind of the reasons behind it,

Brad:

How affairs start. And in the beginning, the person who had the affair may have a hard time showing their pain. We spent a couple of weeks on talking about the 10 different types of affairs, and we talked about how sometimes they overlap. And one of the key themes that overlaps in these affairs is typically the person who has an affair. They're very burned out. They're very vulnerable

Morgan:

To

Brad:

An affair.

Morgan:

The boundaries are lower,

Brad:

Their boundaries are lower. They kind of feel hurt themselves. The negative cycles really beat them up.

Morgan:

They

Brad:

Feel hurt themselves, they feel ignored. They're feeling their own resentment. They're feeling alone. They feel kind of numb,

Morgan:

Disconnected from their spouse, disconnected

Brad:

From their spouse. And what happens is, is they start to care less about the marriage. And for many people, it's a wake up call, oh my gosh, I really do matter. They really do love me. I see how much they're hurting. And so you may not get this instantaneous, oh, I'm begging for mercy kind of thing. But eventually, once you kind of work through things, they're going to be able to get to that place and show that vulnerability. It's there many times it's there, but you may need that in the beginning. And with the negative cycle keeps 'em from being able to do that. That's why you need

Morgan:

Help. Would you like me to go ahead and do benefits of forgiveness?

Brad:

Yeah, go ahead, Morgan.

Morgan:

So letting go of resentment, hatred, bitterness, and desires for revenge is a way to come to peace with the past. So that's a lot of what we're talking about here, just letting it go of those things that kind of eat you up inside. The first step in the process of forgiveness is realizing that no offense against you is worth destroying your peace of mind. When individuals forgive, they take responsibility for their happiness. That no longer depends on the betrayer to make them happy so they don't depend on outside forces to make them happy. And you really can have that peace of mind. You really can come to that place where you're stronger. And so that's what we're talking about. Those are the main benefits of forgiveness. You want to add anything to that?

Brad:

Yeah. I would say many people might've heard of Viktor Frankl.

Morgan:

Oh yeah. He

Brad:

Wrote Man's Search for Meaning. He's a Holocaust survivor. And one of the things you said, Morgan, it's really important. That reminds me of what he said.

Brad:

You

Brad:

Said, I'm kind of paraphrasing what you said, but you said forgiveness is a process of realizing that no offense against you is worth destroying your peace of mind.

Brad:

Yeah,

Brad:

Absolutely. And that's kind of what Viktor Frankl's book Man Search for Meaning was about. Basically, no one can steal your attitude but yourself. No one can steal your happiness, but yourself.

Morgan:

He was a Holocaust survivor, and he chose not to have bitterness towards what happened to him.

Brad:

He chose to keep his attitude. That was the last thing someone can take from you is your own attitude, your internal sense of happiness. And so he was able to control that. Morgan, I want to move on to false forgiveness.

Brad:

Okay,

Morgan:

Good.

Brad:

And this is important. Let me just explain what I mean by false forgiveness. False forgiveness. This is something that occurs when both partners want to move on and they avoid having a confrontation about the affair. They just kind of rather

Morgan:

Just gloss over it

Brad:

And talks about it. Yeah, gloss over it.

Morgan:

They

Brad:

Have this, they avoid things kind of mentality. Pretend

Morgan:

It didn't happen,

Brad:

Just

Morgan:

Pretending,

Brad:

Just tell me it's not going to happen. We'll sweep it under the rug together. And so there's a false forgiveness. The affair happened. And so rushing forward for that is a way to stay in denial about what has really happened and the pain that it's caused.

Morgan:

So nothing gets resolved, really. The issues before don't get resolved. The issue of the pain doesn't get resolved and going forward, it's just

Brad:

Yeah, exactly. And so when this forgiveness is rushed or hurried because it's the right thing to do, unquote, that can lead to deep resentment later. When people do

Morgan:

That, they can't be close, right?

Brad:

No, they can't be close. Very hard to be into it. Yeah, it's very hard. And usually when that happens, that's because the betrayer is pushing for it. Just forgive me. Forgive me. And the one who has been betrayed, the injured spouse, from my experience, they typically go along with it because they're more fearful about losing that person. Just their presence and connection. They need them. And so they'll kind of whatever, I don't want to push 'em away. And they typically don't stay in counseling very long. So that can lead to deep resentment later because they're having to eat it stuff, it sweep it on the rug, and that's not something they typically want to do. And it is a sad fact that some people actually think about their spouse's reaction when debating an affair. Some people will have an affair and they'll think about how their spouse is going to react, and they're weighing the pros and cons as they do it. And if they feel like their spouse will quickly forgive them, they'll falsely believe, oh, well, it's a little bit of punishment for the thrill of a lifetime.

Morgan:

Oh my gosh,

Brad:

It's going to be a couple of weeks. I'm having my one night stand, or my fun or this or that. I know my spouse is a pushover.

Morgan:

Oh, that's horrible.

Brad:

And these are typically people who do that are pretty narcissistic, self-centered people, that kind of false. It can promote a pattern of cheating like that. It just reinforces someone who's really self-centered.

Morgan:

Narcissistic. We've been talking about forgiveness in the context of infidelity, right, Brad? And today we're going to talk about why can't you forgive me, right?

Brad:

Yeah. We're going to talk about common reasons why forgiveness has not happened yet. Last week's show, we talked about exactly what is forgiveness, and we talked about how people benefit from forgiving. There's health benefits we didn't really get into, but obviously peace of mind is one of those. And we talked about the dangers of false forgiveness, how you forgive somebody when you forgive. You don't always, if you have false forgiveness, you're kind of letting that person off the hook

Morgan:

Without healing from it,

Brad:

Without healing, and without them doing the necessary steps to help you heal.

Morgan:

We also talked about two different types of forgiveness.

Brad:

There's a type of forgiveness that is about letting that person back in because you find them safe and trustworthy. And that way when you feel like they're safe and trustworthy, you can lean on 'em and become emotionally vulnerable. And then there's another type of forgiveness. It's more about for yourself, it's more about letting yourself off the hook. You're letting go of that need to punish. You're letting go of your own resentment and bitterness. Hatred and hatred, typically, you can't let that person in unless you have forgiven them. And you're letting go of your own anger, your own bitterness and your own resentment. And typically, so if you don't have that, you haven't forgiven them and letting go of your need to punish and for revenge.

Morgan:

If

Brad:

You haven't let go of that,

Morgan:

It's very hard to move that other to that type. It's very hard

Brad:

To move to that other type of forgiveness. And then the week before that, we talked about myths of forgiveness. Sometimes forgiving means forgetting. Sometimes people falsely believe, well, if I forgive, that means I'm approving of their immoral behavior. It'll make 'em think they can do it again. They can do it again. They didn't have an impact on me. It means I'm weak if I

Morgan:

Forgive. And those of course are myths because it's really actually a show of strength to be able to move through this pain

Brad:

And forgiveness is a process too. So that's kind of what we talked about. And let's talk about why people get stuck in their inability to forgive. Basically something that people talk about is why can't you forgive me? There are difficulties that spouses who've been betrayed have when it comes to moving away from the bitterness towards an attitude of forgiveness and understanding forgiveness with a couple. There needs to be mutual empathy. Both spouses need to feel compassion from each other, and both must ask for forgiveness for the part they played in the marital problems they had in the past. Many times a spouse's ability to forgive is based on their partner's genuine efforts to make amends.

Brad:

And

Brad:

So you got to feel like that person is there as a healer. And again, this is when you get stuck in that negative cycle that we've talked about numerous times. It makes it really hard to let go. Yeah, definitely make amends. And so common reasons why forgiveness hasn't happened yet. And I would say the first is as long as the injured spouse believes that they are a victim, and life has been ruined, their life has been ruined by the affair, forgiveness will be impossible to give.

Morgan:

It's living in that self pity. But it seems just so hard to do. I mean, that's one of those things that, I mean, your life has been turned upside down.

Brad:

Yeah. Well, Morgan, that goes back to what you said last week, I think is so key. You said the first step in the process of forgiveness is realizing that no offense against you

Morgan:

Is

Brad:

Worth destroying your peace of mind.

Morgan:

It's true. And the Victor Frankl

Brad:

Quote, yeah, Victor Frankl, that's really important because a common reason people can't forgive is they think their life is over. They don't realize that they can rebuild. They haven't seen other people rebuild or they don't know enough people that have couples that have been able to move on.

Morgan:

And you have more strength than you think. Sometimes it feels just impossible. But the truth is that you have more power in the situation than you truly believe you do. The second common reason why forgiveness hasn't happened yet is if injured spouses believe that the affair is still happening, they just can't forgive because they don't feel safe and they can't let their guard down. I mean, gosh, if it's still happening, how can you move forward if they're still having an affair?

Brad:

Yeah. I mean, you can forgive. I forgive you. It's my duty to forgive you as a Christian. I need to forgive you as a person. So I forgive you when you're seeking God's help, but to let that person back in. I mean, there's really very, very little chance you can be vulnerable with someone when you feel like they're still hurting you. Your tendency when we're hurting is to start protecting ourself.

Morgan:

Yeah. It also feels like, well, maybe they aren't fully remorseful. I mean, they're still doing what they should not be doing if they really want to make this work. Does that make

Brad:

Sense? Yeah. Another common reason why people can't forgive or it hasn't happened yet, even though the affair could be over, the spouse who's been betrayed, they feel like there's been no precautions taken to protect the marriage against future infidelity. So they feel unable to let their walls down because they feel vulnerable to know their fear happening. There's a key theme here, why forgiveness hasn't taken place yet. And that theme is there isn't enough safety there. And so people need to feel safe for them to let go of that resentment, that bitterness, that revenge, the need to punish. Because when people haven't forgiven so way to protect themselves, that hurt is there as a way to take action against being hurt again.

Morgan:

So some of what this might be saying, precautions haven't been taken yet, or maybe they're still working at the job with the person that they cheated with.

Brad:

Yeah, that's a big one.

Morgan:

They're still on the computer late at night when they know that's what led to their problems before. So they're still stuck.

Brad:

They're still keeping secrets. They're still not being honest. They're still not being transparent. They still have a password that their spouse doesn't know on their phone or computer, things like that. And that makes it harder to let go and to be vulnerable and to let go of the hurt and the pain because that person isn't there for you. And honestly, you're going to stay stuck in a negative cycle longer.

Morgan:

Absolutely.

Brad:

Because you're hurting and you don't feel like that person is there for you. Kind of like I mentioned earlier, for there to be forgiveness, you need to have mutual empathy. You need to feel compassion. You need to feel like that person is there making genuine efforts to make amends. And if you don't have that, you get stuck. That negative cycle keeps you stuck and being unable to have forgiveness.

Morgan:

Yeah, those feelings of empathy are backed up by action. The fourth one here, common reasons why forgiveness hasn't happened. If the affair is unquestionably over and the involved spouse has made genuine effort to heal his or her injured spouse, the injured spouse may be experiencing pain from the past that has been reawakened by the betrayal. Injured spouses. Ask yourself, if this is further evidence that the world is unfair, were you treated unfairly by family members or in a previous relationship? Is there a history of sexual abuse or deep wounds from a parent bullying in school? Possibly unshakable doubts about self-worth or other issues that may be contributing to your feelings. So is there something from the past, maybe this is brought up,

Brad:

And obviously affairs make someone very insecure and they can hit on other insecurities. But I do want to caution though, some people are hearing this, that their spouse, they're the ones who had the affair and they're jumping up and down saying, yes, yes. I'm glad they said that because my spouse has this. I want to be quick to just kind of jump in and say this. And you need to be really supportive and really careful about pointing out your spouse's insecurities because they may have that, but you need to be sensitive about it as well. They may be thinking, no, it's not the stuff from the past, it's what you did because you're not there. It could go either way. And you need to help with a trained therapist who's worked through this to help you sort through some of that stuff.

Morgan:

And we need to be very careful not to place blame on the injured spouse.

Brad:

Yeah. That can be retraumatizing itself.

Morgan:

Absolutely.

Brad:

Oh no, you're not hurting because I just kicked you in the shin. You're hurting because when you're a kid, you tripped and kicked your shin. You just got to be careful. And that's where the help of a therapist can come in.

Morgan:

Yeah. Qualified, trained,

Brad:

Experienced

Morgan:

Therapist.

Brad:

Yeah. Therapist with experience, not just anybody. Another thing is another common reason why people get stuck in being unable to heal from an affair. Honestly, it's because some people like the pain.

Brad:

It's

Brad:

Almost like they get addicted to it. They keep picking at an open wound and never let wound heal. Many people pass through this on their way towards healing, but some find themselves stuck here. Some people can just kind of get to healing forgiveness quickly, and it's genuine and they're healing from it. But some people get stuck here and I'm talking about they can be stuck here for a long time, like a year

Brad:

At

Brad:

Least a full year later, and they're still stuck in it. And that can be because their spouse, like we've said before, and there's a lot of factors that go into this. Let me be careful. I don't want to just say, if you're a year after this and you haven't made any progress and you're still hurting and obsessing about it

Morgan:

Doesn't necessarily mean you

Brad:

Like the pain. Mean you like the pain. It may mean your spouse isn't helping you. It may mean you're still stuck in a negative

Morgan:

Cycle. It may mean that there is trauma that needs to be handled

Brad:

From

Morgan:

The past,

Brad:

And that can be part of it. But another part of it is sometimes people like the pain. They like the attention, they like the pain. And that can be a form of manipulation. And lemme say this though, in my experience, the one that you just mentioned a moment ago, and the one I'm talking about now, that happens, but it's not super common.

Morgan:

This one here that we're talking

Brad:

About. Yeah, the one I'm talking about here and the one that you just mentioned about maybe issues from the past, those aren't super common,

But many people find themselves stuck here where they like the pain, they like the benefits of that pain. Other people give 'em attention, support. Their spouse has been over backwards, backwards. They like being able to have that control. I've only had probably one person that really has taken this to an extreme level. And so this isn't super common, but the bottom line with this kind of roadblock is that the injured spouse, they feel like if they do forgive, the spouse who had the affair will be off the hook and free from blame and they're going to get off too easily. But let me say this, it should be noted because if the one who's been betrayed isn't able to move forward from this deep emotional pain and they're living in bitterness, they may actually drive the involved spouse, A spouse who had the affair into the arms of someone else. Again, they just kind of feel hopeless. Crud, we're here, we're stuck. Or they may just decide they don't want to be with you anymore. So I wish there was more time we could spend on that one. But one of the things with this, lemme just, I want to kind of wrap that up as best I can.

Sometimes people like the pain, they don't know how to deal with the pain. Many people dunno how to deal with it, but the ones who like it, they kind of get addicted to dealing with it. Those feelings, that's rare. I mean, this isn't like every person that gets stuck in it. That's pretty rare, I would say.

Morgan:

Gotcha, gotcha. Well, the sixth one that we are talking about, why forgiveness hasn't happened yet spouses who are caught up in their own hurt are not able to see the affair from their husband or wife's point of view. So part of the process of achieving forgiveness for injured spouses is being able to give up the role of the victim and see things through their partner's eyes. So that empathy there, when the pain is still fresh, it is very easy for them to be absorbed in their own injury and not be able to forgive, have compassion or understanding. And it is quite hard because you are nursing your own wounds to be able to see through your spouse's eyes. But it's very important

Brad:

To

Morgan:

Get to that point.

Brad:

And what you just said there is really important. There are still hurting so deeply and so much that they can't. It's almost like you're in so much pain yourself, and this is what couples experience, not just with infidelity, but in our office, when they get caught in that negative cycle, they're experiencing so much pain themselves that it's really hard for them to know or see where their spouse is coming from. And that's really important with being able to get out of that negative cycle. The negative cycle is such an important part of the recovery process. Dealing with that, moving forward with it, it's really, really important. Honestly, that's where marriage counseling comes into play, helping you deal with that negative cycle,

Morgan:

Kind of see the forest from the trees.

Brad:

It's

Morgan:

Very easy to get stuck in the jungle, but being able to see it from the treetops,

Brad:

Well, yeah, you're hurting so much. It's kind of like when you're depressed, times where I've been depressed or people are just this way, when you're depressed, you tend to be thinking about your own situation, what's causing you to be depressed, how the sky is falling in your world, and you don't really think about other people how they're affected and involved. That's sometimes why if you go help someone else who's hurting or suffering, you're going to feel better about your situation. You're just going to feel better, period. And so that's kind of how this pain works. It causes us to turn inward focus on ourselves because we're in a crisis and it's psychologically what we do just to get out of this mess is we become really?

Morgan:

Yeah, but truly it digs you down deeper into it. So stepping out of that and trying to be others focused or outwardly focused have a little empathy. It's going to really help the forgiveness process. So what's next? Questions

Brad:

To off? Yeah, we're going to talk about questions really to ask yourself, are you willing to forgive? How willing are you to do this? Because some people say, oh yeah, I want to forgive and this and that, but they get stuck in it. So here's some questions to ask yourself on how willing you are to forgive. Question one is, was your spouse trying to intentionally hurt you personally or was this behavior a reflection of their own emptiness? So were they trying to hurt you personally or is this a reflection of their own emptiness? Can you make allowances for your spouse's past? I think that's a really good thing to stop and think about. Is this personal or is this them acting out of their own hurt because they're empty and their unhappy in life? Are they doing this to try to intentionally hurt me or are they trying to do it because they're feeling empty?

Morgan:

But I wonder if that person really is trying to be mean and how do you sort through that?

Brad:

Well, to be honest with you, I think that that happens. But my experience that's rare with affairs, it's usually because they're empty, they're burned out, and maybe they do one out of the marriage, but it's not like they're trying to punish their spouse by having an affair. It's not something they generally do. They know their spouse finds out, that's why they're deceptive. They lie about it, they're going to be unhappy, but they're doing that more because they don't want to rock the boat. Yeah, that's a good way to look at it. Not like if they wanted their spouse to know one really hurt them personally, they would be much more honest about it, why it's going on. True. That's true.

Morgan:

Very true.

Brad:

So it's more about their own emptiness.

Morgan:

That's a good point,

Brad:

Yeah.

Morgan:

Got it. Well, that second one is do you want to only condemn your spouse's affair and not your spouse?

Brad:

Yeah. And that's important, Morgan, what you said on how to sort out how willing you are to forgive. Are you only wanting to condemn the affair or are you trying to condemn your spouse? And there's a difference

Morgan:

As a person.

Brad:

Yeah, you're condemning a person. Are you condemning a person or a behavior? And sometimes that line is hard to distinguish, especially when there's a lot of pain in the beginning and couples are caught in that negative cycle. Do you want to give up your ill will towards your spouse? Do you really want to be able to let go and move on? How willing are you to give up that ill will? I know when I was betrayed, I wanted to do anything to get rid of it. The pain at least. And the pain is closely related to that, ill will because when you don't feel any pain anymore, you can begin to let it go. You can begin to fade.

Morgan:

And the next one, do you want to shift your focus away from the affair towards the positives in life? That's a question to sort out whether you're willing to forgive. Do you want to focus on the positives or do you want to focus on the affair?

Brad:

Yeah, and that's a good one. Again, this is hard to do in the beginning, and I'm afraid that people who are listening to this and they hear us talking about that depends on where you're at in the process. The first 90 days are the toughest, the toughest. And if you're listening to this and you're involved in the first 90 days, maybe even the first six months, and you're saying, Hey, he just said right there on the radio that you got to start thinking of being positive, that's going to be hard to do. There's a lot of factors you need to think about. Am I doing what I need to be doing to help my spouse heal? And you probably need to be in counseling. Am I doing what I need to do to help my spouse

Morgan:

Heal or myself to heal

Brad:

Or myself to heal? Focus on yourself, listen to your spouse, try to do all that, but work through the negative cycle. And so many times the one who had the affair is like, Hey, be positive. They really minimize where their spouse is coming from and honestly, it's really stupid.

Morgan:

Yeah, it's not helpful at all. The next one, do you want to trust your spouse again? Do you want to trust your spouse? Ultimately, if this all goes well and you could have complete healing and this great relationship, do you want to let them back in? Do you want to trust them? I think that's a good question.

Brad:

And that shows a willingness of how willing you are to forgive. Do you want to trust them again? I think that's a great question on the barometer of how willing you are to forgive is do you want to trust them again? And do you want to give up hurting and hating them?

Brad:

Do

Brad:

You want to give up your own hurt and do you want to give up your own hating them? That's an important question to ask yourself on how willing you are to forgive.

Morgan:

And I think a lot of people that comes in the form of, I don't want to hurt anymore. I just don't want to have this crushing feeling anymore. I think that's a good way to know if you want to give up the hurt.

Brad:

And Morgan, I just want to kind of briefly go over this. We're coming up on time, but I want to go over a common question that people have. How do I know I won't be betrayed

Morgan:

Again? Oh, yes, that's a great question.

Brad:

Yeah, it's a fantastic question because this is something that I hear often and I mentioned, I referenced that in our last show. Even when relationships are moving forward after an affair and it's doing better than expected,

Brad:

The

Brad:

Injured spouse typically has a common question that I hear in my office, and that is, how do I know I won't be betrayed again? How do I know I won't be cheated on again, this checklist I'm going to give you guys, this is really important as far as giving you peace of mind about how likely another fair is to happen again.

Brad:

Okay,

Brad:

And so the first is, do both of you understand appropriate boundaries concerning friendships of the opposite sex?

Morgan:

Oh, that's so important.

Brad:

It's

Morgan:

Crucial.

Brad:

It's crucial because it's hard. Well, it's crucial, at least for many times people have affairs. They just violate some of the most basic boundaries. I mean, just things that I consider common sense,

Morgan:

Just talking too much, too long, giving information to the other person that maybe your spouse doesn't even know. Sharing personal feelings about even the smallest things sometimes.

Brad:

Yeah, we've had numerous people just go to music events with someone who wasn't their spouse. It's like a coworker or a friend. I'm like, are you serious?

Brad:

Yeah.

Brad:

And so it's just silly, but understanding appropriate boundaries also helps in the healing process. Another is, are you both committed to being honest about attractions to the opposite sex and to everything related to your relationship? That doesn't mean that you're going to go have an affair if you're attracted to someone else, but at least you need to be honest about some of these attractions because that helps prevent any acting out. It takes away the fantasy element if you discuss that with your spouse. It

Morgan:

Brings reality to it for sure. And definitely that secret, that small little secret thought that happened in the day that sure does grow sometimes and it can lead to something. So I'll do the next one.

Brad:

Yeah, go ahead.

Morgan:

You both have friends who are a hundred percent supportive of your marriage. I think this is so important because people will say, I just want you to be happy he's done this or she's done this to you. Let's go to the bar and drink it up and we'll just forget that

Brad:

They

Morgan:

Ever existed and that's just not,

Brad:

And the other thing about that is commonly talking about marital problems with friends and family. I wouldn't say it's a leading cause of divorce, but it's a factor that contributes to divorce

Brad:

That's

Brad:

Not really always considered. I wouldn't say it's a leading cause, like money issues or sex issues or things like that, but it's a factor that influences people to start thinking, well, my parents don't like him. My parents don't like her,

Morgan:

And my mom is constantly talking about

Brad:

My friend. How

Morgan:

Horrible.

Brad:

Yeah, you only get one side of the story. So you want to have friends and family who are a hundred percent supportive of the marriage that you go to for marital problems. For the sake of time, I'm just going to go through the next few of these. You both have the same understanding of what commitment and faithfulness means

Morgan:

Being on the same page.

Brad:

Yeah. You both agree on what monogamy is. You both agree on what an emotional affair

Morgan:

Is and what's okay and what's not.

Brad:

That's important because a lot of people just disagree on what an affair is. They don't understand that there's different warning signs or different types of affairs, emotional affairs. Some people think it's only intercourse. Some people think it's other types of sex is

Morgan:

Okay. Some people think pornography is okay when it's just not.

Brad:

So you both have the same understanding of what commitment and faithfulness means. Obviously that's something you want to talk about before you get married. And so anyway, the next one is you talk to your spouse about vulnerabilities and warning signs without either one of you being defensive. You can talk about vulnerabilities, warning signs without people becoming defensive.

Morgan:

So glad that you were honest and telling me that you felt that way, that kind of thing. You acknowledge and are working on problems in the marriage that could weaken your

Brad:

Commitment. Yeah. You're acknowledging and working on those things that are issues that are factors that hurt the marriage, and that's so important. You show that you care about each other even in little things. That's so important. Doing the dishes, doing the dishes, doing the laundry, cleaning the cats, litter box.

Morgan:

Those are things that are on his honey-do list. And the last one, you have made your spouse a priority over everyone else that's important.

Brad:

And Morgan, I would even add, and this is a key one, you're out of the negative cycle. You're out of the negative cycle. That's so important

Morgan:

And that's how you'll know that the betrayal won't happen again or very likely,

Brad:

And you feel more emotionally secure with each other. You feel like there's dependability there, the emotional connection is there. Those are all things that are important that you consider

Morgan:

Safety. Safety in the relationship.

Brad:

The second type of forgiveness that we're going to focus on is forgiving to let that person back in.

Morgan:

And the first one was about letting

Brad:

Go of resentment, revenge, hurt, anger, bitterness, things like that.

Morgan:

It's kind of for yourself.

Brad:

Yeah, it's more for yourself. Now, this is when you're working towards reconciliation, you're working towards resolving things, fixing the marriage, and so you can have forgiveness without letting that person in. You can do that. You can forgive someone who has really hurt you without them becoming part of your life. Now. This is about how they become a part of your life after they've really hurt you. The steps necessary to begin to heal,

Morgan:

To reconcile the rules. To reconcile.

Brad:

Yeah. This is so important because many times in couples counseling with couples, when there isn't an affair, we will help them work past conflict. They've deescalated, meaning they're fighting less, and when they do fight, it's less intense, but they're not feeling closer emotionally. Just because there's an absence of conflict does not necessarily mean there is emotional

Morgan:

Closeness and a great relationship

Brad:

And a great relationship. It can still say surface, and that's because generally there is a time in the past where one of the spouses felt abandoned and they really needed their spouse and they felt abandoned. Kind of my term for relationship injury comes from a feeling of abandonment that is accrued by an event or a pattern of behavior during a time when a person really felt like they needed their spouse or their partner

Morgan:

And they just weren't there for 'em

Brad:

And they weren't there. So after we experienced a relationship injury, we put up a wall that keeps our spouse out that says, I will not let you in. I'll not depend on you again for anything. And so we feel like it is easier to do things on our own instead of relying on our spouse. And we have found our spouse to be untrustworthy or dependable

Morgan:

And not safe.

Brad:

Yeah, they're not a safe person in a way. They're kind of dangerous. So we just find 'em untrustworthy, undependable, we quit relying on 'em. A wall goes up and we reason to ourself, it's easier to do life on my own than open up to this person and need this person.

Morgan:

There's kind of a distance that's between you and your spouse. It grows and grows and grows until things

Brad:

Happen. Yeah, it's a big distance. Recently I had a couple where I worked with them on a relationship injury like this, and sometimes they involve health emergencies, pregnancies, obviously infidelity.

Morgan:

Death in the family.

Brad:

Death in the family.

Morgan:

You weren't there for me when my father died.

Brad:

Yeah. Crisis, things like that. Moments when you need somebody,

Morgan:

And that's not always physical closeness that can be emotional closeness.

Brad:

Yes, I need, it's more about the emotional closeness. I need to rely on you.

Morgan:

You weren't there to comfort me or something like that.

Brad:

Yeah, it's usually things like that. But one of the key things is these wounds are there. Sometimes they're not ever discussed and sometimes they're obvious to both parties, sometimes they're never discussed. And if they are, a negative cycle can almost be triggered just discussing it

Because somebody is labeled as a monster and a horrible human being for allowing this to happen. And just the way it's brought up many times it can trigger a negative cycle. The person who's the accused, so to speak, they think, you think I'm a horrible person, you think I'm a monster? And so they get defensive and it creates this negative cycle around it that makes it really hard to resolve and heal from. So we're going to go through the steps here in a second, but why this is so important, resolving these relationship injuries like this, and many couples that come into marriage counseling have 'em. Many couples obviously when there's an affair have these. And so why is it important? Well, just because there's an absence of conflict doesn't mean that there's an emotional connection. So resolving this allows the person who's been hurt to become emotionally connected again and risk relying on their spouse or partner again. And so that's really important.

Morgan:

Let me just for a point of clarity, when a couple has experienced these pains in their relationship, you're saying that they need to discuss those issues and talk about the hurt surrounding that abandonment or those injuries before they can begin to fully forgive and let their partner back in and feel vulnerable with that partner. Is that what you're saying?

Brad:

Yeah, I am saying that. I'm saying in order to really forgive that person and let 'em back in, you have to feel like as the person who's been hurt, you have to feel like that person is safe and no longer going to hurt you.

Morgan:

Okay? And that's what we're going to talk about and that's what we're going to talk about.

Brad:

And here's the secret. If you don't get anything out of this, and you're the one who's hurt somebody, how they get over this, and this is the big secret, is you have to show them you're hurting because hurting.

Brad:

You're

Brad:

Not hurting because you got caught or you're not hurting because they kicked you out of the house. You're hurting because you've devastated them. That's the only way they get past this, and they need an explanation that makes sense. They need to understand your thought process, not you getting defensive, but you explaining who you were, why you did what you did as a way to make yourself more predictable to 'em. That's kind of the whole secret with this. And they need to sense from you that you're really in pain about this. They don't need to sense that you're angry or that you're upset, though you may be that. But what's really underneath that frustration is what really is going on is you're really sad about this. They need to see that sadness, that remorse that you have because you are heartbroken that you've caused this kind of pain. That's how that person begins to let you back in. If they don't sense that you are undependable, unreliable, you're just not safe. So of course they're not going to let you in.

Morgan:

Yeah. And you'll get stuck in this cycle. Talk

Brad:

About, yeah, you're going to get stuck and you're not going to really be able to have an emotionally close relationship or marriage. Again, here's the other thing. Why this is so important is this is what the betrayed spouse needs to heal. They need to know that you're in pain about hurting them, that you're ashamed of yourself, that you feel guilty about this, that you're disappointed in yourself. They need to know that, and you need to show 'em that. You can't just assume that they know that because you feel that way or that the reason you're staying up at night is because you are guilty and you feel remorse. They need to hear it from your mouth. They can't just assume that because if you're up at night and you can't sleep, they may think you're missing the affair partner. They may think that you're still in love with that person and you're having withdrawals from them. You need to be very clear and explicit, I am grieving how I've hurt you. They need to know that. And you can't just assume they know that. You need to show them that. Many times in my office when I'm working with couples, I'll ask, how do you show your spouse you're feeling sad or remorseful? And many times the answer is, I don't. Or if they do, well, I get angry. Or spouse is like, well, no, duh, I don't know that you're upset or you're angry or you're sorry for what you did. You don't tell me that and I don't sense it from you.

Morgan:

All I see is anger. Yeah.

Brad:

All I see is anger. How am I supposed to know you feel guilty about hurting me? You don't ever tell me that. And because they can't do that or they're not doing that, of course the spouse can't rely on 'em again. So Morgan, let's focus on kind of the steps of forgiving a relationship

Morgan:

Injury. Okay, awesome.

Brad:

It's very simple. We're going to go through these steps and remember this, spouses who've had affairs, it's always easier for your spouse to forgive you when you feel your spouse's pain. That's really key. It's also easier when your spouse feels safe that another affair will not happen again. And you have to show, not just have words of apology. I'm sorry, I apologize. But you have to back that up with actions

Morgan:

That

Brad:

Show your're truly sorry,

Morgan:

And you're accountable.

Brad:

Yeah, you have to have that because healing obviously can't take place if the affair is still occurring or they sense that it's still occurring and you have to show yourself as someone who is taking responsibility for this. And so we're going to get in a little bit more detail.

Morgan:

And trust is built over time.

Brad:

Yeah, it's built over time. But this is a huge point in rebuilding that marriage and relationship. And this isn't just a one time event. This is something that you have to show

Morgan:

Over and over

Brad:

Sometimes again, over and over again. Often, I don't know the number of times you have to show it, but I know it's a lot. I don't know if there's ever a limit to the number times you show the pain that you're in. But recently we had a guy that was caught in numerous affairs. He was more distraught about his wife acting very upset than he was about actually healing her pain and he couldn't show her this. So obviously they stayed in a perpetual negative cycle they couldn't get out of.

Morgan:

Do we want to talk about the steps?

Brad:

Yeah, I'll go ahead and start with the first one, Morgan.

Morgan:

Okay.

Brad:

Like I mentioned earlier, the spouse who's been betrayed or injured with a relationship injury, they really need to be able to recognize and articulate the injury caused by the affair. Remember, you want to express these emotions without yelling or attacking your spouse or partner. You need your partner to hear what you were saying without feeling defensive. And also you need to let your spouse know you felt deprived, dismissed, deserted, devalued. You need to let 'em know you really felt abandoned.

And here's how you do that. You do that by tapping into what's called primary emotion. And the best way I know how to explain primary emotion is most of the time we only show secondary emotion. If we're feeling sad, which is a primary emotion, we may show anger. Or if we're feeling sad, we may just kind of shut down and get quiet, or we may show frustration or worry. Those are all secondary emotions. And secondary emotions don't really move a person. And what you want is you want to tap into the sadness that's there, the fear that's there. And you know what I've noticed, Morgan? It's really easy when there's an affair for people to tap into, especially when they've been betrayed, to tap into that primary emotion. But many times it comes out with criticism and attacks as well. You're being vulnerable, but you're also spewing hatred. You're spewing attacks, things like that. And that really makes it hard to heal. You're kind of shooting yourself in the foot when you do that. And here's primary emotions. Here's examples of primary emotion, and there's only maybe six, seven emotions. Talk about the hurt. That's not really a primary, but it helps you access that primary. Talking about the hurt, talking about sadness,

Talking about fear, talking about shame or disgust that you have talking about.

Morgan:

What about loneliness is that

Brad:

That's a secondary emotion. Secondary, yeah. Sadness, fear are going to be primary emotions that you're going to talk about a lot. Shame is going to be a primary emotion. The betrayer will have, guilt is more of a secondary emotion, so disgust with yourself is going to be important. There's also anger is a primary emotion. Anger can be secondary, and I hope I'm not confusing our listeners, but anger can be both primary and secondary. It's primary when it's used to defend yourself. It's also primary when you're using it to enforce your boundaries. And so it's more secondary when it's used to attack someone else. So anyway, those are some examples of primary emotion. There's also positive primary emotions like joy, surprise, excitement. Those are positive primary emotions. But when you articulate this injury that was caused by the affair, talk about the primary emotion that's there, and here's why primary emotion is so important because it moves your spouse,

Brad:

It

Brad:

Causes them to have more of a tender heart towards you. It causes them to feel more compassion towards you. It causes them to have more empathy for you. It causes them to really hear you. Many times in my office when we get into primary emotion, people aren't fighting anymore. They're listening to each other because they're actually seeing the impact that their behavior is having on their spouse. And so that's a key thing. And so articulate, recognize, articulate the injury. If it's a pattern of behavior, try to find an incident that really hurts the most and go after that incident. Recently had a couple, the same couple I was talking about a moment ago where the wife was pregnant and the husband wasn't helping out, and this is a common scenario, but she was doing all this housework and he was watching TV by himself, and she's really kind of doing real physical housework.

Well, she gets an attachment injury from that. And talking about this really makes it much harder when you don't get into the primary. If you talk about the primary, it helps. But what happened with her is he's always been this way. It's a pattern of behavior. And she was able to recognize a one time event that occurred, and it made it much easier for him to realize, oh my gosh, I really dropped the ball. And so it may be a pattern, but there may be one event focus on that event. It helps sometimes resolve this. But if you can't go with that pattern of behavior,

Morgan:

And that was a relationship injury that she felt like he wasn't stepping up and taking,

Brad:

She surely felt hurt

Morgan:

And helping.

Brad:

Yeah.

Morgan:

Okay. Yeah. So the second step here is as the involved spouse or the spouse that maybe had the affair or created the injury, realize that some apologies don't work. Examples of apologies that don't work are maybe I did have an affair, but I guess you expect me to apologize. You can't let this go until I apologize. So all of these are forced token apologies that come nowhere near correcting the damage that's been done by the affairs.

Brad:

And those don't sound very sincere,

Morgan:

Morgan. No. Right?

Brad:

Well, maybe I did have an affair, but there's going to be a huge but huge reason for having an affair. Maybe I had an affair, but you always criticize me for years. Or just something silly.

Morgan:

Didn't scoop the cat box like that one person said,

Brad:

Yeah, it's just silly. But the other is, I guess you expect me to apologize. That's not very,

Morgan:

That's not sincere.

Brad:

No, you can't let this go and dull. I apologize. So here's my apology. And here's the thing is like I mentioned earlier in the show, in order for an apology to work, it's the feeling and the emotion behind it. You need an apology because that's an acknowledgement of the pain that's necessary. And acknowledgement of the pain is necessary. But you have to show them, I am hurting because you're hurting. I'm hurting because I see you hurting from what I did. I'm so ashamed of myself and my actions. I'm so sorry for hurting you.

Morgan:

Not that you're an inconvenience, and your emotions and feelings

Brad:

Are because those kind of token apologies that you gave examples of,

Morgan:

There's one too. I'm sorry you feel that way, or

Brad:

Yeah, that's not a real apology that people can heal from any sort of big relationship hurt.

Morgan:

And

Brad:

To have an attachment injury or relationship injury, you really have to have some serious relationship hurts. And so that ties into what I'm saying here. Those types of apologies don't work. Well, here's five elements of an effective apology. The first is you have to care for their pain. And the second is you acknowledge that their hurt is legitimate. You have legitimate right to be hurt.

Brad:

You

Brad:

Have to let 'em know that. The third is you take ownership of your hurtful actions.

Morgan:

I did this, I did this, and it hurt you.

Brad:

Yeah, you take ownership. Four is you express shame for your behavior. Five is you assure your spouse that you're willing to help them heal. So you have to assure them, I'm here to help you heal. This isn't going to happen anymore. There's no more text messages, phone calls, no more out of town trips with this person. No more.

Morgan:

You take my phone, take my email account passwords, please.

Brad:

You're showing yourself willing to be a healer. And the people who heal the best are able to do this. The couples that heal the best are able to do this. And granted, not every couple who's had an affair is in this place coming out of the gate to be able to do this. But this is where you should be working towards. And like we talked about before in previous shows, many times people who have an affair, they're kind of burned out. But once you're back in it, you need to be able to do this in order to heal. Those are elements of an apology that make it effective. And again, the big idea is they have to sense from you, the one who did this, that you're in pain

Brad:

Because

Brad:

They're in pain. Your pain is tied to them hurting, and it's not I'm in pain. I got caught or anything silly like that. I'm in pain because I see how hurt you are.

Morgan:

And it's sincere and it's sincere

Brad:

And

Morgan:

Honest. Yeah. Let's talk about this next one, talking to the involved spouse. Again, help your husband or wife understand your personal weaknesses and emotional vulnerabilities that contributed to the affair. So explain these weaknesses and vulnerabilities without blaming your spouse for the affair.

Brad:

Really

Morgan:

Assess where did you get permission? How did things degrade over time for you that caused your boundaries to be lifted and caused you to fall into something like an affair?

Brad:

Yeah. Another way to think about this is you want to try to help your spouse understand why you responded the way you did at that moment.

Brad:

Yes.

Brad:

And really what that's about is you're going to have to dig deep and you may even have to discover for yourself how that evolved, how you got to that place.

Morgan:

Yes. How those boundaries degraded. Exactly.

Brad:

And think about this though as making yourself more predictable to your spouse. And what I mean by that is you are dangerous to them after an affair. They're scared of you. And so you have to talk about this in terms of helping them see you is less dangerous. They have to understand your thought process, where you're coming from. They have to understand a great deal of that, and it has to make sense to them. And so you may have to dig deep, discover what's going on and share that and discuss that because part of that healing is you're just making yourself more predictable,

Morgan:

More of what was happening for you inside versus the environment. Because that environment could be accusatory. It could be saying, well, you were pregnant and I was lonely, and then I decided to do such and such.

Brad:

They have to just, the best way is you're just making yourself more predictable. Here's my thought process. Here's what was happening. Here's what's happening. Because you're less dangerous. They can read you better. And understanding that helps them know why this happened, but also they can feel more protected from it happening again. And then the next step after explaining that you want to really recognize their pain and you want to apologize. And again, the elements of that apology are caring for their pain, acknowledging that their hurt is legitimate. Taking ownership of your hurtful actions, expressing shame for your behavior, sharing your spouse that you're willing to help them heal. And when you do that, it's about acknowledging their pain and you helping take care of it. You want to take ownership of your actions and you want to show that you're willing to do whatever it takes. Lemme say this apology isn't about the one who had the affair. It's about I'm showing you my pain. And let me say this, Morgan. There's some individuals who've had affairs who were really just so disgusted with themselves. It takes a lot for them to dig deep and show this kind of remorse. And because they feel it

And it's there for them, they just assume that their spouse knows it. Let me repeat that. Yeah, you may be feeling it and it may be very legitimate in there and real, but your spouse has got to see it from you.

And this is something that sometimes you're going to have to initiate. I'm really sorry. You're going to have to bring it up on your own and talk about it, because when your spouse feels like you're not sorry for it, and they're going to live in fear of you and they're going to stay at that place where the wall is up, they're going to stay guarded. They're going to stay afraid of you, and they're going to stay afraid of it happening again. And so recently I had a couple where the husband, the only time he's ever able to do this is when he's in our office in therapy. And the wife loves coming to counseling because of that. But outside, he doesn't do that. And it actually causes him to stay stuck in the negative cycle because she's afraid of him and it's very real fear and naturally. And so it makes it really hard for her to trust him because she doesn't see that as often as she needs to see it

Morgan:

Outside

Brad:

Of counseling.

Morgan:

Outside of counseling, him being open and

Brad:

Him being open and then sharing that he is in pain because she's in pain and it's there. It didn't take a lot of probing to get it out, but it needs to be something that initiates, he initiates any shows. Morgan, do you want to do the last one?

Morgan:

Sure. So we talked about, well, we also have injured spouses. I mean, do you accept the apology? If you can at this point, the relationship can begin to move forward and you'll be able to leave behind the resentment.

Brad:

You'll be able to start leaving behind the resentment. You can start letting yourself get closer. But again, a lot of that is based on the betrayer. Where are they at? The one who did this? Are you making them feel safe? Are you there acknowledging the pain? You care for their pain? This isn't a onetime thing. I know we're kind of talking about it in terms that there's these steps. It's like a onetime event, but really what? It's ongoing.

Morgan:

It's ongoing

Brad:

And it needs to continue to happen every day as much as the one who's been betrayed needs it.

Morgan:

And sometimes these apologies, they just don't penetrate. They don't go to the deepest part. They have to hear it over and over sometimes because it's very hard. And they have these questions that keep coming up and keep coming up until they can fully process it. It's going to take some time.

Brad:

Step six is, do you accept the apology that you just kind of went over? Step seven is discuss as the one who had the affair, how you intend for this never to happen again, or the one who abandoned your or hurt your spouse. How you never intend for this to happen again. And so you need to be specific about what you expect moving forward and what you can't tolerate happening. Obviously, healing won't be able to take place if it's still occurring. And these are the steps for healing, working through relationship injuries like affairs, even other types of relationship injuries, really anything that's created a wall and emotional distance. And it doesn't have to be things as big as affairs to do that. And these steps that we've gone over, they work with affairs and other relationship injuries. This is a thing that really needs to take place early on in the affair recovery process. And then

Morgan:

What if your spouse is not available to forgive if they're not

Brad:

Healing by yourself?

Well, that is a fantastic question. And just briefly, I want to go over one way to heal, and really it involves letter writing. You want to just take out a pen and paper and here's a sample of what you can do. You want to write them a letter saying you forgive them, and you can say, dear so-and-so with all of my might, I forgive you for all the betrayal and hurt you have caused me. I've released the burden of ill will towards you now and free me and you to live without this guilt, resentment, hatred, anger. And so that's kind of a sample. Lemme say this, if you share some responsibility for hurting the betrayer or whoever else, your spouse who left you, or if you carried extreme resentment, you might ask them to forgive you as well. And you can include a statement when you write this letter about forgiving yourself and sign it and date it. And then some people find it helpful to burn it.

Morgan:

Yeah. It may not want to send it, and you want to maybe have to write it over and over every day until it becomes true.

Brad:

Yeah. Write them a letter letting them releasing them. Thanks for listening to Healing Broken Trust. If you like this episode, you can always get our show notes and more details and links to the resources we discussed@healingbrokentrust.com. Also, as long as you're online, head on over to healing broken trust.com/retreat for details on an upcoming one-on-one retreat with me. If you like us, please subscribe and leave a review for us on iTunes. As always, everything discussed on this podcast is either my opinion or Morgan's opinion and is not to be taken as relationship advice because I'm not your therapist, nor have I considered your personal situation as your therapist. This podcast is for your entertainment and education only, and I really do hope you've enjoyed it. See you Until next time.

Ep 24: How To Move On So The Affair Doesn't Define Your Life, Strategies for Overcoming the Mental Battle

Jim:

At some point you have to deal with things. If not, they just build and build and build the inevitable with the divorce. I mean, we were going to get divorced 14 months ago. If we'd have found you, I wouldn't be here where I'm at right now.

Morgan:

Have you been wondering how to break free from the affair once and for all? Now's the time to take back your life, your emotions, find happiness, joy, and fulfillment with your marriage. Healing Broken trust.com is the place where you can find resources to take the healing journey to the next level. You'll find incredible resources for every stage of your fair recovery journey. Connect with our team of qualified Affair recovery therapists who stay current with the ever-growing, ever-changing affair recovery research that's available to help you heal wherever you are in the process. Take our home study course focused on helping you communicate and express yourself in a way that gets you what you want. You can also book an incredible one-on-one intensive retreat where instead of dragging out the pain over months or years, you can condense the time it takes to heal in just a matter of days.

Using scientifically proven methods that work to help couples lower their guard, let go of the fear, melt the anger, and experience each other at a deep emotional level you may have never experienced before. So what are you waiting for? Go to Healing Broken trust.com. But don't take our word for it. Read the client letters and listen to the reviews on the Healing Broken trust.com website. At the end of this episode, you'll hear directly from a couple whose relationship was transformed because they worked with Brad. So go to Healing Brook and trust.com and we'll talk to you soon. Hello and welcome to Healing Brook and Trust podcast with your hosts, Brad and Morgan Robinson. We are excited to be here with you to help you heal your relationship after infidelity. So Brad, what are we talking about today?

Brad:

Well, we're going to talk about post-traumatic growth, what that is, what it looks like, and how to attain it. And honestly, Morgan, I'm really excited to be talking about this. This is probably one of my top two favorite subjects in the fair recovery discussions, and we haven't even got to the second one yet. And so we've been talking about all these things. The thing that I love probably even more than this, is bonding events, which we haven't talke d about in any of our podcasts yet.

Morgan:

And

Brad:

So I don't know what podcast number we're on, we're in our twenties, but here we are really getting to some stuff that's some of my favorite topics to talk about.

Morgan:

Oh, yeah.

Brad:

So I'm really happy about that

Morgan:

For couples to bond and go through those change events.

Brad:

And we will talk about that later. We haven't, like we said in our very first podcast that this was a radio show that we had done and we'd edit it into a podcast format. But this is our first live recorded, recorded podcast because some of those recordings are actually three, maybe almost four years old by now.

Morgan:

That's right.

Brad:

And so it's really exciting just to kind of bring you guys new information, just different things that we haven't talked about before. And since that time, post-traumatic growth and binding events are two of my most favorite topics that we didn't even record anything on when we had the radio show.

Morgan:

Yeah. Because research and the training and all the information and the knowledge just gets better and better and better experience. Oh, yeah.

Brad:

But yeah, it's a lot of fun. And with post-traumatic growth, this is what that really is. It's been defined as a positive change experienced as a result of the struggle with a major life crisis or traumatic event. So it's this positive change that you experience as a result of major pain, of major setbacks. And what's really important with this Morgan is to understand that the normal response for human beings when they face trauma and crisis and pain isn't to go under, but actually to become better. And the usual response is resilience and growth, not defeat in the face of adversity. And so sometimes that's our normal response is to have that to go under, but we can rise above it, and that's the normal response. There's things that we can help ourselves experience post-traumatic growth quicker. So we don't have to go through all this up and down roller coaster ride, but we can get there much quicker. And that's really what this whole thing's about is getting there. So it's not something that rarely happens. It's something that it's not unusual for people to bounce back from infidelity. And to be honest with you, when two people are in my office and they want to make it work, I'm surprised when they don't make it work

When they really want to make it work. And the one who had the affair has cut off the affair and they're being honest, and the one who got betrayed is scared to trust, but they're willing to trust and willing to let their guard down again. I think people always work through those situations.

Morgan:

And

Brad:

So I'm surprised if somebody doesn't work through it when you're willing to put it into work and what it takes.

Morgan:

Yeah. So what you're saying is the norm for couples who experience infidelity that you've worked with is to rebuild with a stronger wood, to grow with deeper roots, to build on rock instead of on sand that they're gaining that closeness, they're gaining that security with each other that they've maybe never experienced before. And so infidelity was just that catalyst that caused them to reach deeper, to grow stronger as a couple.

Brad:

Absolutely.

Morgan:

And as individuals, I imagine.

Brad:

Yeah. Well, the thing is people are tempted to throw in the towel, but when they don't, they resurrect with something greater.

Morgan:

Absolutely.

Brad:

They rise from the ashes with some scars of course, but also new confidence in their marriage and in themselves that they could literally overcome anything as a couple.

Morgan:

Absolutely.

Brad:

Which is a great place to be. Sometimes betrayal causes people to really recognize what matters in life, what matters to them spiritually, what their marriage matters to 'em. Time with my kids being a better parent matters to me. People have a wake up call with these kinds of things.

Morgan:

It kind of can pull you out of being selfish too. A little bit more selfless

Brad:

At the end. Yeah. Well, for both spouses, instead of letting little things waste their time, they found ways to spend more time with each other, and they realize that they lose their spouse, they'll lost everything. As a result, there's a new appreciation for their spouse.

Morgan:

Yeah, absolutely. And so really this is a milestone that a couple should shoot for that's entirely within their reach. As you've mentioned. And we've mentioned in this podcast, creating secure emotional bonds is really the best method for preventing an affair. And it's also the best intervention for repairing your bond after betrayal. And so this post-traumatic growth is really something that you can achieve.

Brad:

Well, and let me say this too, part of those securing emotional bonds, and we're going to talk about this later and really listen for that because it's one podcast you don't want to miss. It's one episode you don't want to miss. I think honestly, it's probably going to be the most important topic that we discuss because it's really going to talk about how to really gain lasting healing long-term, being transparent. Those are early steps that you have to have so you can get out of the discovery phase and get into the trust building phase of a relationship. So you got to be transparent and you got to be honest and open, but that alone doesn't cause people to truly heal. And what people need to heal is they need to go to the depth of their vulnerability and just be emotionally naked and say, here I am with all my blemishes here. I am emotionally naked with you. Do you still want me? Do you still like me?

Morgan:

And then for their spouse to be able to respond to

Brad:

That in

Morgan:

A loving, healing, caring

Brad:

Way. And that's what brings about the true change. And there's different three different areas that takes place in, and a lot of people find it very hard to do on their own. So we always recommend working with a marriage counselor. We've got two locations in Oklahoma. You're welcome to fly out and visit with us or visit our therapist in Oklahoma City, the team out there. These are folks that are trained in how to help couples work through this.

Morgan:

And of course, you can find out more information@healingbrokentrust.com for that, but we're not trying to sell you on that

Brad:

Ground. No, not at all. But I want you guys to be aware of that because there is something that's kind of a next level deeper that I'm shocked that nobody really talks about. Some of the bestselling books on infidelity. Nobody really talks about that. And so in fact, we haven't talked about it so far.

Morgan:

Right. Going to coming to visit us. Yeah. Bonding events. Yeah.

Brad:

Well, I'm talking about bonding events

Morgan:

Too. Oh, bonding events.

Brad:

Yeah. But post-traumatic growth isn't something that's rare. It's actually very frequent, but it isn't something that happens on its own. So we have to work with

Morgan:

It.

Brad:

We must put ourselves in a position to bounce back from adversity. We must do the right things to rise from this crisis. And that's what this podcast has always been about. It's about giving you the necessary tools to bounce back and experience post-traumatic growth.

Morgan:

Absolutely. And so many times, the door to growth in life is also the same path that's marked with suffering. So we kind have to go through the fire to be refined. In some ways, pain is what causes us to change and change for the better. It's always kind of uncomfortable to make that change, but that's how we make the change is going through it,

Morgan:

Not

Morgan:

Trying to avoid it when we start to get depressed or we get anxious or we get angry if we push away the change or the Yeah,

Brad:

Absolutely.

Morgan:

The feelings.

Brad:

Yeah. You got to ask yourself, what am I supposed to learn from this?

How can this make me a better person? I always, I may be getting ahead of myself, but I always like to ask myself, how can I not let this suffering go to waste? How can I capitalize on this? And we were just talking about that this morning with something else completely different, but just something in our lives. We're going to go through this experience again. What can we learn from it? Let's reflect on this and discuss it and write down our conclusions so that we don't make the same mistakes again. And you have to do that to experience post-traumatic growth because it's not always automatic. It's normal to experience it, and you can experience it even if you're in hell right now, but you got to work with it to get there. It's not something that happens on its own. And so something that I learned that helped me build resilience, and when I'm facing adversity, it's oftentimes, I'll think back to the story of Joseph in the Bible.

Remember the first time I heard about that? I think I might've been a teenager, maybe heard it when I was younger, but I remember hearing the story of Joseph in the Bible where he gets sold into slavery by his brothers. They grew tired of him. He was kind of a prideful young man. He was his dad's favorite. And his dad let everybody know about it. And he ends up in Egypt after spending time on their prison, he becomes a high ranking member of their government. And it's at that point, he sees his brothers again, who betrayed him. There was a famine that caused many people to starve in that region. And Joseph was in charge of managing the food supplies. And close to the end of Joseph life, he was in a position to kill his brothers, but he did something remarkable. Instead, he forgave his brothers.

And this is what he said. I think this is one of the most profound things written in the whole Bible. He said, this is what Joseph said to his brothers, when you sold me into slavery, you meant it evil against me, but God meant it for good to bring it about that many people should be kept alive as they are today from the famine that occurred. And so I think that's really important. Like Joseph was saying, if we could bring that into maybe more modern vernacular, he was saying, you guys meant it for evil. What you intended to do was to kill me or murder me, or just get you out of your life or hurt me, hurt me beyond repair. And sometimes that's what people do when they betray their spouses. It's the deepest wound I think people can go through. And I've talked about how I've had people who've been shot at before. I've had people who've gone through all kinds of ridiculous situations who've consistently said being betrayed by their spouse was the worst thing they ever went through. So anyway, but what this is saying is you meant it for evil, but God meant it to bring about greater good.

I think that's a key reason that we suffer. I'm not a theologian, and obviously there's people listening with different beliefs than us. We respect those beliefs

Morgan:

Absolutely

Brad:

Or no beliefs at all. And that's fine too. But you have to have a belief that life is happening for you, not against you. And you have to believe that things are working for good and they're moving you towards your goals even when it feels like a setback. You have to really believe that

Morgan:

Absolutely.

Brad:

Because if you do post-traumatic growth is going to be easier. One of the wrong conclusions to make is to close your heart up after you get betrayed

Naturally. You're not going to trust your spouse. Sometimes people do the most hellacious things when they betray their spouse involved in so much deception. That's going to be normal to not trust your spouse. Again, I'm not saying be an idiot and just blindly trust your spouse. Again, use your own common sense. But what I'm trying to say is if don't kind of assign the whole world as cursed, cursed or broken or fallen, or you can't trust anybody else again, when I got betrayed before I met Morgan, I had learned the wrong lesson from that betrayal. I had said, you know what? I put all my eggs in one basket. I don't need to ever really give my heart to someone ever again completely. I need to kind of keep a little bit back for myself. I learned the wrong lesson in that. And it's only later that after kind of doing this for a living that I kind realized, you know what?

There's still a part of me that kind of held back and I got to recognize that. But that was a wrong lesson to learn. And so people oftentimes learn lessons like that. I think that's the wrong lesson to learn. So anyway, you've got to have this belief no matter what your spiritual values are or your beliefs are, you've got to come to the place where you realize life is happening for me to move me towards my goals. And it's happening to make me better and to bring about good in my life and good in the lives of others.

Morgan:

So I am going to take this opportunity to, while I'm hurting, yes I'm hurting, but I'm going to take this opportunity to grow and to find the silver lining, no matter how hard. And if you have the days where you don't feel like there's anything good, don't worry. It takes some effort. It takes some time. If you have a terrible, terrible day, just take it. Okay, it's just a terrible day. Tomorrow will be better. And you have to pull yourself up by your bootstraps in some ways emotionally and just say, you know what? This is a bad day. It's going to be a bad day today. That's okay.

Brad:

And it's okay to have bad days. Yes, that's normal. Absolutely. And let me say this, Morgan, because we're not talking about wishful thinking or

Morgan:

Shoving down

Brad:

Feelings or shoving down feelings or denying reality or things like that. What we're talking about is it's more of a choice. I'm choosing to look at things this way and believe that eventually good's going to come out of this. Because when I got betrayed, I did not see any good coming out of that. I had put on about 30 pounds in 10 months. I did not see how anything positive was going to come out of this. At that point in my life during marriage counseling, obviously I wasn't helping couples yet, but I didn't even see how I can see God's hand now in it. I mean, look what I do now for a living. I am an international expert on betrayal and helping people work through it. But if I didn't have that experience and didn't really know what it felt like myself, I think I would severely lack a lot of the compassion, empathy, empathy of what it's like because it just, part of you dies when you guys are stuff like that. And it took me a while fully to get that back. I was arrogant. I didn't go do therapy. I needed to, I was worried about what they were going to tell me that somehow I had, it was based in my childhood because your parents' divorced. That's why this bothers you so much. And so I was worried about what the therapist would think of me that I didn't go get the help that I needed.

And a lot of people do that, but this is definitely an appropriate time to go get help. This is almost like a personal nine 11 or a personal terrorist attack. This is something that nobody would question you if you went to therapy after a terrorist attack. The people in nine 11 and how godawful and terrible that was, nobody looks at them and says, you're weak for going to talk to somebody

Or you're weak to go get help. But this is the same thing. You're not weak to go talk to a therapist. You're not weak to go see a marriage counselor. It's a totally appropriate time to do it. And so go, because part of therapy is part of how you get to that post-traumatic growth. And so I'm getting a little off our notes, so lemme get back to our notes. But one of the things that typically people have to have to achieve to achieve post-traumatic growth is really develop their spiritual roots. So you got to develop your spiritual roots, whatever they are, because that sometimes enables us to see a larger picture. It allows us to see a grander plan. My mother, she had cancer, it just came back this past maybe 18 months, and she tripped and fell in the shower and hurt herself, hurt herself pretty bad. But she went to the doctor. She's approaching 70. So she went to the doctor, got it checked out, and it turns out they did some scans. And it turns out the cancer, the breast cancer that she had 10 years ago had maybe nine or 10 years ago had returned and it actually had spread to her lungs.

Morgan:

And they wouldn't have known that had she not fallen in the shower

Brad:

And herself had she not fallen in the shower herself and kind of bruised the rib herself. And so that's kind of a microcosm, that's obviously not maybe your story, your story is my spouse has cheated on me or I've cheated on my spouse and I might've done it multiple times or they might've done it to me multiple times. But you've got to believe that there's something greater working on your behalf. God, he's working on your behalf to bring about good. And so my mother gets it checked out and they're able to give her some drugs and they're making a lot of really good advances with cancer now. But if she hadn't found that if she didn't trip and fall, she might be dead right now.

Morgan:

Yeah, that's very

Brad:

True. And we just had our first child. That would've been

Morgan:

Really sad.

Brad:

It would've been terrible.

Morgan:

And so you may be at home thinking, oh my gosh, I can't believe they caught me cheating. Or they caught me in the sly. Or they saw these text messages and it's very embarrassing and it's very hurtful. And you may be thinking, oh my gosh, my life is over. But if you talk to someone on the other side of the healing process, they'd say, well, thank God that they found these text messages. I wish I had told them myself, but thank God they found this because now I have this weight lifted off of me can actually start rebuilding the marriage. They're actually, so it doesn't seem like it's this wonderful gift, but in the end, yeah,

Brad:

Absolutely. And you got to have a long-term perspective with this because for several years I did not even see what's the plan with me getting betrayed. And not everybody who gets portrayed is going to turn out to be a marriage counselor, but you have to have another's focus to get off Tony Robbins. I like that guy. He says that the root of your suffering is that you're too focused on yourself. So go out and help other people. I think a lot of suffering happens to actually help us love better. Jesus taught us to love our neighbors ourself. I think a lot of suffering happens because it's really meant to make us more compassionate and empathetic

Morgan:

And

Brad:

Love other people more.

Morgan:

And what does depression, it's anger turn inwards. Well, if we can pull out of ourself and we can go and look at other people, maybe you start focusing on your kids. How are they feeling during this time focusing on maybe volunteering or getting out there and loving others like Brad is saying, it can really do a lot to pull you out of the depression. So that's one idea.

Brad:

And so let me get back to our notes. I'm getting off a little bit, but so the people who are able to bounce back and experience post-traumatic growth, they're able to see the good that has been produced by their suffering. They may not be able to see it right away because of the pain and the trauma of the betrayal is too great, but they know that they are suffering because it's for the greater good and unseen forces are working on their behalf. As crazy as it sounds, when I experienced setbacks or failure, and I don't do this always as quickly as I would like, but something I have tried to make it a habit of is to say to myself over and over again, this is good because it allows me to see my options. Because you can get stuck in a negative situation and just see

Morgan:

It all

Brad:

Crumbling. Well, you just see you're focused on the failure

And what you're focused on. It's going to determine your attitude and the mood you're in. And again, sometimes some hurts are just so big. And most people who get betrayed, I would probably say 99.9% of them are not able to do what I just mentioned. So if you can't do that, that's okay. One of you may be listening can do that. We've got a lot of people listening to us all over the world. And so if you can't do that, that's okay. But try to get to that point eventually where you can say, you know what? This has been a good thing for us. This has been a good thing for me. Even if it's kind of tearing your family apart, you've got to see the good in this situation, focus on the good. But you also have to, and we haven't discussed, I think I did, but you've got to talk to somebody about this stuff to really get the full effect of post-traumatic growth. You've got to do work on yourself. And that's something that I've had to do to work through hurts. I've experienced

Morgan:

Mine. Me as well.

Brad:

Yeah. Morgan, you've had to do that.

Morgan:

And even if in the beginning, this is good. I woke up this morning, this is good. I've gotten up out bed this morning. I am on my feet this morning. I'm eating breakfast. Yes, this is good. Even the small things start with the small things. I'm not crying this very moment. This is good thinking about those moment by moment situations because life may not feel good, but you woke up this morning, so that's good.

Brad:

Yeah. Morgan, something that we talk about often is when we're going through something bad, obviously this is good, but it's that idea of let's not let this suffering go to waste. What can we learn from this? Let's talk about it. Let's write down our conclusions. Let's type it up so that I'll keep it and kind of be able to reflect on it and go back to it because it's like, what am I supposed to learn out of this? What is God trying to help me through this?

Morgan:

And what you meditate on most of the time is what you kind of bring about in your day. So renewing your mind with some truth is really

Brad:

Helpful. Yeah, absolutely. But I think an attitude like that lends itself to post-traumatic

Morgan:

Growth. Absolutely. So we're not trying to offer up cliches, but things like what we're talking about here have really helped us. And so actually was over a year ago that we had went on vacation with your dad and

Brad:

A couple of years ago. That's right. It was a few years.

Morgan:

Oh dear Lord. Has it been that long time? My goodness. Time flies. And we took him along because he was getting older and we wanted to make some memories before he passed. And the first day on the trip he shared with us that he had bladder cancer. He was,

Brad:

Well, he started to pee blood.

Morgan:

That's right.

Brad:

And he showed me his urine. And this is a little disgusting. It's gross, but it looked like pink lemonade. You could see flesh coming through his urine and it looked like part of the lemonade. And so obviously our vacation after that

Morgan:

Wasn't very relaxing.

Brad:

It wasn't very relaxing at all. And my dad at that age was 74, went through two rounds of chemo and they didn't think he was going to make it. I really thought my dad was going to die. And so he eventually had to have his bladder removed. And that whole process lasted about a year. Very scary for us. I didn't want to let the suffering go to waste. So I took this as an opportunity to grow from it, and I wanted to learn something from this. And what I learned from that was I need to have an active and healthy lifestyle myself. I went up to where he was getting chemo at, and everybody in there was overweight that day. And I guess, and I'm not a cancer expert, but from my understanding is that most individuals who tend to get cancer tend to be more overweight and obese. And so it made me really take my health as a priority. My dad had been at Green Beret Special Forces, and I was a few years older than him by the time he had gotten out. But I was in a completely different physical shape than him. And this is him at 74 overweight, and this is me and

Morgan:

His age back when he got out of Green

Brad:

Parade. Yeah, yeah. He's like tip top shape, physically fit. And I'm like, catch potato. Don't really do anything physically. But that led me to changing my habits, and it resulted in me losing 35 pounds

Morgan:

Because thinking, oh my gosh, he was way in better shape when he was my age. And I'm thinking, oh my gosh, I'm only going to get worse if I let it go down path.

Brad:

If I don't do anything. There has to be an intervention.

And that was a good experience for my dad, helped him grow spiritually in a way that he never had before. It's good experience for me, health-wise in some ways was a good thing for our relationship. I got to talk to him about things I probably would never would've talked to him about, but it gave me a new perspective in life. It made me want to be here for my own kids. It was a wake up call. Those are some examples in my own life with my dad, the whole thing that I became becoming a marriage counselor working with infidelity, I don't think this podcast would be here had I not gotten betrayed. I wouldn't have been fascinated by betrayal.

Morgan:

This is really interesting. As you're talking about your story, it might be good for me to share a piece of my story. I was also betrayed a while back, and I've had to think and think through, well, how did I gain any post-traumatic growth from that? But I do realize now that sure, I experienced a lot of shame, a lot of personal shame. And I remember my self-esteem just was shot. It was in the toilet. But looking back now, I think, you know what? I dumped him. I broke up with him even though he had cheated on me, and I didn't realize that I walked out that day when he got angry and whatever. So at that moment, I was able to stand up for myself in a way that I hadn't been able to stand up for myself before. And so I didn't realize it at that time.

I didn't see that there was some kind of strength there that I was learning and gaining. But many years later, which is now, I can look back and say, you know what? I learned to put my foot down and value myself in a way that I hadn't really valued myself. And so you can maybe say that that's a post-traumatic growth experience. I mean, I had a lot of growing to do after that, but that was the first step to me saying, you know what? I'm not going to accept this. I'm not going to accept being treated like this.

Brad:

Well, it's going to be the first time that you really recognized that to stand up for your needs and assert yourself in that way.

Morgan:

Absolutely.

Brad:

And have healthy boundaries.

Morgan:

And of course, we weren't married. It was a dating relationship. So I know that just dumping someone is not necessarily the easiest or the right choice for everyone.

Brad:

Yeah, you were right.

Morgan:

You

Brad:

Were much younger than you are now. Much,

Morgan:

Yes. Different situation,

Brad:

Different stage of life. You probably weren't as attached as you would be to somebody that you're married

Morgan:

To. I didn't have children with the person. It wasn't anything like that. So I don't suggest people to just drop 'em and walk out the door. Not your situation all the time. Maybe you may be a different situation. But the point that is, you can stand up for yourself and stand up for what you need and stand up for your self-worth and stand up for what matters to you, which is your health, emotional health, physical health, mental health, and say, you know what? I'm not going to accept this. And if you want this relationship to work, if you want this to work, I'm going to put my foot down and say, we need counseling. I need this. I need that. Because sometimes people just don't know how to do that. Maybe you're like me. Maybe this is a moment for you to step up and start deciding what you want and need in the relationship and asking for it. And again, you might need help to do that.

Brad:

Yeah. I mean, don't go this alone. I mean, I think our podcast is fantastic. I think what we talk about is stuff. I really believe in support, and it's going

Morgan:

To help

Brad:

You

Morgan:

Even if you are in counseling and go to our website. We have resources

Brad:

There. Yeah, we got great stuff. It's really stuff that we spend a lot of time putting our heart and soul into. It's great. But I'm just saying that to illustrate the importance of going and talking with somebody who knows your situation, who's familiar with betrayal, how to heal from infidelity, who can work with you guys as a couple, if that's an option for you, go do that. That's so important.

Morgan:

And that's how post-traumatic growth comes about in the long run, right?

Brad:

Yeah.

Morgan:

So I know this is something just I'm sure is on a ticker tape going through your mind, but some of you might be thinking, Brad, you're nuts. Morgan. You're nuts. You don't know my situation. The person who betrayed me should be executed. I mean, sometimes you just might be really angry, and I totally understand.

Brad:

Well, and sometimes people who betray their spouses are really bad people. They can be really, but that's not everybody.

Morgan:

Yeah, that's not.

Brad:

And sometimes we feel like they're a psychopath. They're not really a psychopath. We're just hurting. Yeah, we're just hurting. Or they're narcissistic and they're not really a narcissist. But the thing is, this post-traumatic growth stuff works regardless of your situation. It's a belief. It's an attitude

Morgan:

Whether you stay together or not, whatever.

Brad:

But if you do stay together, it's something that will make your relationship stronger. It's really having one of those strong marriages and where you feel emotionally safe and secure with each other.

Morgan:

So let's get to this kind of in a nutshell, what does it take to get to post-traumatic growth, Brad?

Brad:

Okay. What it takes to get to post-traumatic growth is it's really a belief. It's a belief that life happens for you, not to you. It's a belief that when you suffer and you go through things, that greater good is coming out of it. It's a belief that setbacks are actually leading you towards your goals. It's worth repeating. It's a belief that life happens for you, not to you. It's a belief that when you suffer, when you go through painful things, that greater good is coming out of that. It's greater good for you, greater good for other people, but ultimately greater good. And it's a belief that setbacks, failures, pain are all moving you towards your goals in life. You have to have that kind of belief so that you can start doing the things that are necessary to overcome this kind of trauma. This is again, the hardest thing that people go through.

Morgan:

That attitude

Brad:

Shift, that attitude shift. And I want to quote, going out of this podcast, I want to quote the founder of Domino's Pizza. I'm reading his biography called Pizza Tiger. Don't ask me why I'm reading it. I know it's random. You'd be surprised by the stuff I read.

Morgan:

Yeah. He's been really loving it. He reads me well, it's a

Brad:

Great book.

Morgan:

Quotes from it all the time.

Brad:

It's a great book. What I like about the book, and it was written I think in 86, and what I like about the book, and it's random. I don't even know how popular they are anymore as a pizza chain, but the guy became a billionaire. I'm really impressed with the things that he's doing now. He's pledged to give away all of his money. He's doing it to some great causes and

Morgan:

Founder of one of the founders of Ave Maria

Brad:

University. Ave Maria University. But what's really great is his book. He's talking about all his failures and you can see ultimately

Morgan:

Unabashedly too.

Brad:

Yeah. I mean it's very transparent and very open,

But all these failures I'm getting, he's living through this and you're like, holy crap. He almost lost his company twice. He almost goes bankrupt twice. Some serious setbacks. And one of them is, his attitude on failure is really revealing, and it's what allowed him to experience post-traumatic growth. And this is what he says, and we'll close with this. He said, failure is how we learn. Failure strengthens you to find the seed of benefit that every adversity contains. Your greatest strength is to turn adversity into advantage. Every time you suffer a setback, ask yourself, how can I turn this into something good?

Morgan:

Yeah,

Brad:

It's good. So I might say that one more time. People may be driving. Failure is how we learn. Failure strengthens you to find the seed of benefit that every adversity contains. Your greatest strength is to turn adversity into advantage. Every time you suffer a setback, ask yourself, how can I turn this into something good? And that my friends is how you do post-traumatic

Morgan:

Growth. Absolutely.

Jim:

At some point you have to deal with things. If not, they just build and build and build the inevitable with the divorce. I mean, we were going to get divorced 14 months ago. If we'd have found you, I wouldn't be here where I'm at right now. I went three months. I couldn't work. I couldn't sleep. I cried every night. I was depressed. I couldn't eat. Health started going downhill. I couldn't put it in a box and let it just let God take care of it. You have to deal with your problems. You don't deny 'em.

Brad:

Jim, did you feel like the other help that you got, it was dismissive of where you were coming?

Jim:

That's the best way to explain it. Dismissive. It

Brad:

Was dismissive. It was is, are you going to cheat on me again? Oh, okay. You're not Jim. You got to be satisfied with that.

Jim:

Yeah, that's what they told me. That was one of the words. You have to be satisfied with that.

Brad:

Yeah, I've heard that before from other people.

Jim:

You

Brad:

Just got to let

Jim:

Go. You can't build trust back on that. Yeah. Because when this happens, you feel so alone. And the main thing, and this is what impressed me about you, you listened. You listened to my needs, and then we started chiseling away at those things.

Brad:

Jim, you actually felt like you were getting somewhere. This guy knows what he's talking about.

Jim:

Proactive and reactive is the best way to describe how I felt about your actions. They were proactive and you were reactive to my knees.

Brad:

Yeah. Jim, I remember the first time I met you, we met for three hours.

Jim:

Yes.

Brad:

And you really, how did that time go? That first time you met,

Jim:

It seemed like 15 minutes, but I walked into your office. It was either come to your office or go see my attorney and get the divorce paper started. I mean, I was ready to move on with my life. I'd had enough of a feeling like this every day

Brad:

And explain that what happens after an affair is made known. The person who's been betrayed many times developed symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder. It's very traumatic. That's something that happens when somebody's been raped, a victim of or survived war or battle, natural disaster, an auto accident witnessed somebody die in front of them. This is all, this happens when infidelity occurs. And what happens is it's very traumatic. There's not very many people who are skilled and that know how to help people through this who know how to give hope, who know how to paint a roadmap and who have experience in helping couples through this. And kind of what I've been talking about with Jim is, Jim is I'm the third therapist that Jim has been to, third counselor that Jim's been to and this, he went to these counselors more in the beginning of the process. Is that right, Jim?

Morgan:

Very beginning

Brad:

And now. 14 months later. Never got anywhere with it. And Jim is finally,

Jim:

He just created more questions,

Brad:

Just created more questions, more turmoil, coming closer to divorce. I want this to end. And Jim found me online and for the first time has hope and relief and knowing that it feels like things are better. Things are getting better. I'm not there yet, but I'm getting there. Jim got stuck into a 14 month holding period because nobody gave him any good advice. They were dismissive of Ray. He's coming from, and basically told him just to shut up and be quiet, to go along, accept it and move on with your life. Just accept it and move on. And Jim, you found somebody who actually knew what they were talking about, knew how to deal with it, and you've done more in the last month,

Jim:

The trauma, the first thing, and you said that to begin with, we have to deal with the trauma of this that's so misdiagnosed. People don't understand the level of trauma that this creates. It affects every aspect of your life.

Brad:

Yeah. Yeah, it does. Jim, I like what you said earlier, just as far as the detail you gave. I like what you said, sleep, eating every area of my life.

Morgan:

Yeah,

Brad:

Work everything. There wasn't any, it was overwhelming.

Jim:

That's a good way to describe it. It is. It's overwhelming. I've just went through 14 months of hell through this. I've learned more about who my wife is, so I know better how to understand her and deal with issues that we have in the future. I can be more proactive towards our relationship instead of reactive to our relationship.

Brad:

Yeah. Jim, let me ask you, with what kind of help did you get along the way? Because you found out about

Jim:

Four, two months ago. Oh, we bought every book published. I've read almost every piece of information on the internet, but it's different at three o'clock in the morning with your bloodshot and tears running down your face, try to read and digest this information. It's the third person effect going on. You're still alone. You're sitting in a dark room, you're looking at a computer screen. There's no personal feelings whatsoever being transferred. Your body language, your tone sets the stage for a harmonious transaction between your patience and yourself. The first thing you told us is you're not a judge. You're not here to beat people up. You're a referee. You're here to make sure that information that we need to know gets out there without anybody's feelings getting hurt or nobody fighting.

Brad:

Yeah. I remember with your wife, I wanted to really make, drive it home, and I'm going to be fair with her.

Jim:

Yep. Yep. You did that every meeting.

Brad:

Yeah. I really wanted to let her know she's just a more timid type person, and I didn't want her to feel like she was being dominated. I want to set the stage that this is going to be a respectful process. Give me feedback. I don't want to be disrespectful either. Good marriage counseling requires that. It's

Jim:

Very important.

Brad:

And I think

Jim:

That's the misperception that people go in to counseling. The affected party is looking for vindication, like you talked about earlier. The willingness to forgive is the ability to quit punishing that person. And when you go into marriage counseling, I think all of us are looking for, Hey, this guy's going to be on my side. This person's going to be rooting for me. I got him in my corner. Let's beat her up and let's find some answers or beat him up and find some answers that didn't take place. What took place was a very comfortable place to be able to communicate very emotional things.

Brad:

Yeah. So Jim, you were thinking, this is going to be, he's going to tell me I'm right, that I have the right to leave her, that I'm this, that I'm that.

Jim:

Yeah. That's what I was looking for the first time here was you to say, yeah, Jim, you're right. Go get a divorce. That was what I prayed would come out of your mouth.

Brad:

Oh, wow. What did you find instead?

Jim:

Compassion, understanding. I don't know the word I could really want to use here. It's a harmony. We took chaos and kind of harmonized it a little bit to where we could do the tough things we needed to do. Let those emotions out, dig for what we needed. Tell the truth, be honest. Start building the trust back.

Brad:

I needed hope. I've gotten hope. I know that things are much

Jim:

Better. Oh, you didn't try to talk me out of anything You said. Let's think about this now you are going to, it's, let's think about this.

Brad:

Yeah. Jim, with, so you were kind expecting me to be more of a judge, kind of not a referee, or not a mediator or a peaceful, not a healer. Maybe it's the right way to say it. Not as somebody who's a healer, but somebody who's

Jim:

Telling you, I was looking for a judge, jury, and an executioner

Brad:

When

Jim:

I walked in. Yep.

Brad:

Yeah. Jim, how do you feel about the blueprint of healing that we've had?

Jim:

Well, you gave us a really good path that we were going to take to start with. You sat down and explained the steps, listened to me, diagnose the issues that were the most pressing to me in the beginning and said, this is what we've got to attack first, second, and third. If we don't attack this, we can't go to two. We don't do two in the right order. We can't go to three, and we're going to deal with each one of these issues. And we did. It worked perfectly.

Brad:

So it's before, when we went to other counselors, we didn't have the order.

Jim:

There was no path. There was no process. Do it again. Let's pray about it.

Brad:

And Jim, it was even they would ask your wife, are you going to do this again? And she responded, no, I'm not. And then he

Jim:

Says, they come back and see everything's healed. God takes care of everything.

Brad:

And they expected you to be okay.

Jim:

Yeah.

Brad:

Jim, one of the things you've mentioned earlier was they expected you to Barry kind of put all these in

Jim:

The box. Yeah. Told me I need to forget about it. Forget about it. That I needed to take these negative emotions, put 'em in a box, take 'em outside, bury 'em, and just that God will take care of that. Just go on with your life now.

Brad:

Yeah. And that never got you any closure?

Jim:

No, it made things worse. Life is a wonderful thing. Get out there and live it. Going through this is an existence. It's a very miserable existence at most.

Brad:

Yeah. Yeah. And Jim, for 14 months, I wasn't able to live.

Jim:

No. I lived in a miserable existence of a life, and it was unnecessary because we didn't find the right people to help us.

Brad:

Yeah. Well, I appreciate you coming to me, and I appreciate the help. Yeah, I really appreciate that. And I appreciate you taking the time to do this audio recording.

Jim:

It's been a pleasure. Thank you.